On March 31 police announced the 29-year-old Moore's death was a homicide and Pinney was being charged.
SPRINGFIELD — Police had Frederick Pinney in handcuffs "for his safety" on the day murder victim TayClair Moore's body was found, court records show.
On March 23 police said they were examining the death of a person found at 48 Agnes St. shortly before 1 p.m.
It was being called an “unattended death,” and police said they were awaiting results of an autopsy to see if it was suspicious.
On March 31 police announced the 29-year-old Moore's death was a homicide and Pinney was being charged. Pinney, 45, denied a murder charge Tuesday in Springfield District Court.
According to the request for a murder warrant written March 27 by city Police Officer Timothy J. Kenney, an autopsy done by the state Office of the Chief Medical Examiner in Boston concluded Moore died of asphyxiation, but not by hands and not due to any medical condition.
Kenney wrote, "There were ligature marks on Moore's neck ... There was also evidence of a blunt force injury to her head."
The report said on the day Moore was found dead, Pinney was taken to the Detective Bureau to be interviewed, but was not under arrest. After the interview, Pinney voluntarily was transported to a crisis center for evaluation.
Kenney's report gives details of what police found when they got to the Agnes Street single-family home after Christopher Podgurski, Moore's boyfriend, requested assistance.
Podgurski, who was outside, told police a man inside may have stabbed his girlfriend.
Sgt. Richard Labelle went inside and saw blood on the floor and Pinney in the kitchen, and he "handcuffed him for his safety."
Pinney said there was no one else in the house. Officers looked through the home and found one bedroom door locked. After forcing the door open, they saw Moore on the floor with no signs of life and unclothed.
Police found blood on one side of Moore, but there were no visible signs of trauma.
Pinney had "slicing type injuries to both wrists and his neck."
Podgurski, interviewed at the Detective Bureau, said he had been Moore's boyfriend for 10 years. He said he had known Pinney for three or four years from working together.
Pinney began renting the home in January, Podgurski said. Podgurski and Moore began to move in, renting a room from Pinney, three or four days before Moore's death.
Podgurski said he was in Holyoke with Moore and Pinney for a St. Patrick's Day Road Race party on March 22. Moore and Pinney left to go back to 48 Agnes St., and Podgurski spent the night at his mother's house.
The report said, "Podgurski was aware that both Pinney and Moore were in the possession of cocaine and had done cocaine during the day. He expected that they would continue its use during the evening."
When Podgurski went home March 23 he saw a small amount of blood on the kitchen floor. His room was empty, but Moore's glasses and cell phone were in it.
He knocked on Pinney's door, but first got no answer. In the kitchen he saw three knives, with two having dried blood on them, according to the Kenney's narrative. Podgurski knocked on Pinney's door again, and Pinney told him Moore got mad the night before and left.
When Pinney finally opened the door enough to get out and then closed it again, Podgurski saw Pinney had cuts on his wrists and neck.
Podgurski said Pinney said he had to get the key to open his bedroom door again. When he came back upstairs he had a key in one hand and a knife in the other, according to Podgurski.
When Pinney opened the door, Podgurski saw Moore's legs on the floor. He was afraid of what Pinney would do and went outside and called 911, the report said.
When police got a search warrant for the house they found in Pinney's bedroom: drug paraphernalia, beer bottles, a compressor with a nail gun, a knife, a prescription bottle, a notice for a hearing in Probate Court and a green electrical extension cord with one end secured to the headboard and the other end cut off.
During the police interview with Pinney on March 23, when he was not under arrest, Pinney said when he and Moore got to Agnes Street "he partied with Moore which consisted of alcohol and cocaine."
Pinney said they then went to their own bedrooms, according to the report. He said he has been stressed and had thoughts of hurting himself. He said to that end he took 10 Lorazepam pills and took a knife and tried to cut his wrists and neck. When that didn't work, he got his compressor and nail gun, intending to shoot himself in the head.
He continued to drink and do cocaine and passed out, he told police. He said he and Moore did not party in his room and they didn't have sex.
The report said Pinney was awoken by Podgurski's knocking.
He said he didn't see Moore's body next to his bed and could not explain how it was there. He denied harming her.