Robert Honsch will have a rendition hearing Thursday in Ohio and after that is scheduled to be brought to Western Massachusetts to face a murder arraignment.
This is an update of a story originally published at 3:20 p.m. Wednesday.
SPRINGFIELD – Following an investigation that lasted nearly 20 years, law enforcement in Hampden County, Connecticut, and New York closed the mystery of related “Jane Doe” homicide investigations in Tolland and New Britain, Conn., and filed charges against the man they say is responsible for killing the two women.
Hampden County District Attorney James Orenstein and New Britain, Conn. Police Chief James P. Wardwell separately announced that as a result of a joint investigation, officials have identified the two 1995 homicide victims at Marcia Honsch, 53, and her daughter Elizabeth Honsch, 16, of Brewster, NY.
Marcia Honsch was found shot to death Oct. 6, 1995 in Tolland State Forest; Elizabeth Honsch’s body was found dumped inside some trash bags and a sleeping bag behind a shopping plaza in New Britain on Sept. 28, 1995.
Police were not able to determine their identities until last month.
“No longer will these homicide victims be referred to as “Jane Doe – they will be known as Elizabeth and Marcia; daughter and mother,” said Wardwell.
Finding their identities also led investigators to identifying the man they say is responsible for their deaths, Robert Honsch, the husband of Marcia Honsch and father of Elizabeth Honsch.
Robert Honschcourtesy of New Britain Police Dept.
“This investigation has been long in hours but never cold,” Wardwell said. “Investigators from numerous agencies have worked for long hours to bring the person to justice who killed these two women.”
Robert Honsch was found living under an assumed name in Dalton, Ohio, a small town of about 1,200 people in northeast Ohio, roughly 30 miles south of Akron.
Honsch, now 70, was found living there with a new wife and family.
He is being held without the right to bail in the Wayne County, Ohio, jail, pending a rendition hearing scheduled for Thursday in Wayne County Municipal Court.
After that hearing, he is due to be transported to Massachusetts where he will be arraigned in Westfield District Court on a homicide charge in the death of Marcia Honsch, according to Orenstein’s office.
He will then face a separate arraignment in New Britain on a homicide charge in the death of Elizabeth Honsch, according to New Britain police.
The sudden closing of the case marked a dramatic end to an investigation that has bedeviled police in two states for two decades.
The body of Marcia Honsch was discovered by a hiker on Oct. 6 inside Tolland State Forest. The body, a fully-clothed woman and estimated to be between 30 and 45 years, had been shot in the head.
No one knew her name and she would remain a Jane Doe until just recently.
The investigation was difficult from the beginning because investigators did not know the woman’s name or where she was from, and no one was reporting her missing. As then-District Attorney William Bennett said at the time, "Right now we have a body in the woods and we have no information beyond that.”
A murder in Tolland, an isolated town of about 500 people, was shocking and beyond belief for residents
Then-police Chief Eric Munson III told the Republican in the days after the body was found "Tolland is a quiet town. People tend to joke about our crime statistics because there is no crime. We haven't had a murder in 100 years. Right now there is a lot of shock because people tend to think of these things as happening in Holyoke or Springfield."
Nine days before the body was found in Tolland, police in New Britain were dealing with a Jane Doe investigation of their own. A young girl, estimated to be between 17 and 20 years old, was found wrapped in trash bags and a sleeping bag and dumped behind a shopping center. She too had been shot in the head.
Tolland and New Britain are roughly 40 miles apart.
Composite drawings issued by police in 1995 as part of Jane Doe murder investigations in Tolland and New Britain, Conn. The two murder victims have recently been identified as Marcia Honsch, 53, and her daughter Elizabeth Honsch, both of Brewster, N.Y. Robert Honsch, the husband and father of Marcia and Elizabeth, was arrested for their murders.Courtesy of New Britain Police Dept.
Wardwell said his investigators and Massachusetts State Police detectives in the months and years to follow began to work on a theory that the two cases were related.
Police would publicly link the two cases in 2009, and determine the two women had lived or at least spent time in the greater Albany area.
The Albany connection was determined by Tolland woman’s clothing, which was available only in stores in that area, and by a package of cigarettes that had a tax stamp from Latham, N.Y.
By 2011, officials announced at a press conference that the DNA testing had determined the two bodies were related, and were likely a mother and daughter. The testing, however, did not reveal their identities, and the investigation was hampered by that fact.
Massachusetts State Police Capt. Peter Higgins would say at the time “Identifying the parties is such a crucial thing.”
Once the New York state ties were established, investigators began working with New York State Police to raise awareness of the case in the Albany area.
Composite drawings of the two woman were released, and press conferences where held in the hopes of finding someone who could aid investigators.
Still, as Wardwell noted, “over the years there were no reports of missing persons that seemed to correspond to either victim.”
The big break came last month when New York State Police received a call from a woman from Virginia Beach, Va. who wished to file a missing persons report, Orenstein said. Family members were reaching out to police because Marcia and Elizabeth Honsch of Brewster, NY, had disappeared without a trace 19 years earlier.
New York State Police contacted the Hampden DA’s office and New Britain police, and soon investigators had the information that had evaded them for 19 years: the identities of two murder victims.
With the names of Marcia Honsch and Elizabeth Honsch now known, investigators were able to fill in some of the other blanks that lingered in the investigation. The mother and daughter lived in Brewster with Robert Honsch up until October, 1995.
He was missing too, but investigators found him in Dalton under an alias.
Detectives from the Hampden County DA's Office, New Britain and New York traveled to Dalton to interview Honsch. Police obtained a search warrant for his home and his person. Forensic evidence collected in the search was able to be linked to the New Britain location with Elizabeth Honsch was found.
“This arrest comes as a result of the determined work of many detectives who never forgot this case and worked tirelessly to determine the identities of the victims, and to find out who was responsible for their deaths,” Ornstein said.
He singled out the work of State Police Lt. Stephen Griffin, now retired, for working relentlessly over the years on the case and for seeking assistance from other agencies and the public.
“It is also a tribute to the cooperation of the various law enforcement agencies who worked together on this case: Hampden County State Police, New Britain Police, and New York State Police, all of whom had the cooperation and assistance of local and state law enforcement personnel in the Dalton, Ohio area,” he said.
Map showing locations involved in this story.
View Locations involved in a 1995 cold case investigation in a larger map