The protest and counter-protest groups remained peaceful.
NORTHAMPTON — Supporters of Israel holding signs saying "Stop the Sirens" stood quietly in front of the Hampshire County Courthouse Friday evening as a black-dressed crowd protesting Israel's military campaign in Gaza passed in front of them, marching on the downtown sidewalk to the beat of a drum.
Members of the "Silent March in Solidarity with Palestine" and the small counter-protest remained peaceful, with little apparent exchange between the two groups as the latest conflict in the Middle East continues with no sign of abatement.
The silent march was hosted by the Western Mass Coalition for Palestine, and the Israel supporters were members of Jewish communities in the Northampton and Springfield area, and not under the umbrella of any one group, those present said.
A small group of counter-protesters in support of Israel gathered in Northampton Friday evening. Mary Serreze Photo
Sara Weinberger of Northampton was among those standing in solidarity with Israel, and agreed to speak with a reporter.
"I'm here to let people know that Israelis and Jews are not evil people," said Weinberger. "Our hearts are breaking over the deaths of people in Gaza, as well as the deaths of people in Israel. But we also need to defend ourselves," she said. "When you have thousands of missiles coming over, that's pretty scary."
Weiberger said as the child of Holocaust survivors, "the anti-Semitism I've seen is really frightening — I find that in this community, there just seems to be a lot of vitriolic hatred toward Israel." She said it seems people "don't really believe Israel has the right to exist."
Weinberger said she is confused as to why Israel is being singled out by protesters, when hundreds have recently been killed in Syria by Islamic militants. "Where's the outrage over that?" she asked. "Why is only Israel being put under a microscope?"
Weinberger said Hamas and the people of Gaza are separate in her mind. Hamas, she said, has taken aid money and used it to build tunnels instead of homes, schools, and infrastructure. Hamas does not protect its own citizens, using them as human shields and suicide bombers, said Weinberger.
"I don't think anybody wins in a war like this, but I wish people would realize that this is a horrible situation, and it's not just 'good-guy-versus-bad-guy,'" said Weinberger. "I just want the killing to stop; I just want there to be peace."
Marcy Eisenberg of Northampton said the disproportionate death toll, with far more Gazans having been killed in the conflict than Israelis, doesn't tell the whole story.
"Everyone's heard about the Iron Dome, and the fact that there are bomb shelters," said Eisenberg. "Israel has done quite a lot to protect its citizens, so I don't think mere numbers tell us very much. Hamas is using Gazans as shields. So the disparity is maybe not that simple. I do think that Israel has gone out of its way to try not to target children and civilians," she said.
Weinberger agreed that the Iron Dome missile defense system has kept the Israeli death toll low. "If you think about how many rockets have been fired at Israel, if they didn't have Iron Dome, you would have seen just as many casualties," she said. "I'm heartbroken over those casualties. I'm really heartbroken. But what are you supposed to do when thousands of missiles are being hurled over into your country?"
Weinberger says she believes in the rights of both Palestine and Israel to exist, and hopes that all parties will be able to sit down and negotiate.
Eisenberg said she believes there is not only a war on the ground, but a war in the media, and that Israel is losing.
Meredith Dragon, executive director of the Jewish Federation of Western Mass., was in attendance at the event in support of Israel, but declined to speak with a reporter.
Several participants in the Silent March in Solidarity with Palestine also declined to speak with the press, including a young man with a bullhorn identified by others as one of the lead organizers.
Longtime Northampton activist Patricia "Paki" Weiland said she was marching to protest "the onslaught, the killing of the people of Gaza." She said she was upset about "the death of people I know."
"The question is, who's benefiting?" asked Weiland. "You know, I look over at my friends with the Israeli flags. The Israeli people are suffering. The people of Gaza are suffering. Who benefits? It's the war profiteers. And that has to stop."
Weiland said the situation in Israel and Palestine "can't go back to what it was before this bombardment started. Because that was intolerable."
UMass student Mahamad Barham said Israel is not justified in killing innocent citizens in Gaza. Mary Serreze Photo
Mohamad Barham, a college student with dual American-Palestinian citizenship, said he is a member of the UMass Amherst chapter of SJP, or Students for Justice in Palestine.
"It's time to end the siege in Gaza; the murder of innocent civilians and children," said Barham. "Also for Palestine to have its own state, and its own recognition in the world."
"Just look at the numbers. More than 800 people are dead, most of them are civilians, and a quarter of them are children. How is that justice?"
Barham called for recognition of a Palestinian state, lifting Israeli restrictions on Gaza's economy, and allowing for the free movement of Palestinians into and out of Gaza.
Barham said he does not support Hamas.
"I'm not for Hamas, not for Jihad, not for any group. I want justice for Palestinians," he said.
As for allegations that Hamas is using civilians as shields, and shooting rockets from civilian areas, Barham said that does not justify killing innocent civilians in Gaza.
"Killing innocent civilians because they are being used as human shields is an unacceptable excuse. Too many civilians have died so far. And we want to put an end to it," said Barham.