The proposal to establish a Polish Heritage Historic District has featured a battle about Mater Dolorosa Church.
HOLYOKE -- Debate begins Tuesday (Oct. 14) among city councilors about a plan to establish a Polish Heritage Historic District on Lyman Street.
The council's Ordinance Committee will discuss the plan at 6:30 p.m. at City Hall.
Here's a question-and-answer primer on the proposal:
What is the proposal?
The proposal is to attach the official government designation of historic to 21 residential and commercial properties on the southern part of Lyman Street that supporters said mark an area of Polish heritage.
Why that area?
Largely because of Mater Dolorosa Church. The 113-year-old house of worship at Lyman and Maple streets was built and paid for by Polish immigrants, who came here in heavy numbers between the 1890s and the outbreak of World War I in 1914 to work in the paper and other mills.
District supporters said Mater Dolorosa Church became the immigrants' community focal point.
Why do supporters want such a district established?
Several reasons. As with all pursuits of the historic designation, there's a desire to honor folks from bygone eras by preserving the buildings that they not only built, but lived, worked and worshipped in. Once that stuff is gone, it's not coming back, because neither are the people who created it.
But this case has a unique feature: the battle over Mater Dolorosa Church.
What's going on with Mater Dolorosa Church?
Supporters want the church zipped up in the protective yoke of a historic designation in order to block the Roman Catholic Diocese of Springfield from demolishing it.
Creation of a Polish Heritage Historic District featuring Mater Dolorosa Church would erect that wall of protection, supporters said, because historic structures cannot be altered -- let alone razed -- without government approval.
Why does the diocese want to demolish Mater Dolorosa Church?
That's just it -- the diocese -- most notably through spokesman Mark E. Dupont -- has said repeatedly it has no plans to demolish the church.
But, because the diocese in 2011 merged Mater Dolorosa Church with the former Holy Cross Church, which formed the new Our Lady of the Cross parish based at 23 Sycamore St., Mater Dolorosa Church has been closed and unused. That has left former Mater Dolorosa parishioners bitter and wary about the diocese's plans.
Is there bad blood here?
Yes indeed. Former Mater Dolorosa parishioners don't trust the diocese, based on having their church closed.
Victor M. Anop, of Chicopee, a lawyer and key organizer of Friends of Mater Dolorosa Church, has exchanged nasty comments over the past several years with Dupont.
Anop was part of a group that kept a round-the-clock vigil in Mater Dolorosa Church for a full year after the diocese closed it for fear the bishop otherwise would send in the wrecking ball.
At a public hearing held about the proposed historic district in March, the Senior Center on Pine Street was filled with people. Nearly 40 supporters and foes of the proposal spoke and more than one speaker was booed.
Have there been lawsuits?
You bet: The diocese filed a civil suit in October 2011 after Anop and other vigilers refused to leave Mater Dolorosa Church.
Anop's group countersued later that month. The group charged the diocese "with mismanagement of parishioner-donated funds, civil rights violations through the intimidation of elderly parishioners holding vigil at the closed church and inflating the estimated repair costs to the disputed steeple, among other accusations."
Dupont responded to the countersuit in 2011 by saying, "It is clear through these actions that the individuals involved in this unauthorized occupation of Mater Dolorosa Church have reached a point where they are now willing to cast unfounded accusations, a further waste of time and resources. It is important to note this group does not represent anything close to a majority of the former parishioners."
These legal fights led to the matter going to the Vatican. The Vatican's highest court in Rome is considering the fate of Mater Dolorosa Church.
Why did the diocese close Mater Dolorosa Church to begin with?
Two main reasons:
Because Holyoke no longer had enough Catholics to support so many parishes.
And because an engineer hired by the diocese determined the steeple atop the church was structurally unsound and should be removed.
"It is only a matter of time before there is either a partial or compete failure of the wood framed steeple structure," said the May 2, 2011 report done for the Diocese by Engineering Design Associates Inc. of West Springfield.
So the steeple is a public safety hazard?
Not necessarily. The diocese's engineer's findings were disputed by Neal B. Mitchell, president of Neal Mitchell Associates of Northbridge, which did a report for free for Friends of Mater Dolorosa.
Because of the steeple's "tension cage" structure of timber, bricks and steel rods, Mitchell said in a July 25, 2011 report, "There is no way that this tower will ever fail with this structural combination."
So, back to the proposal: What would the benefits be of establishing a Polish Heritage Historic District?
Historical Commission Chairwoman Olivia Mausel said the benefits would include protecting distinctive buildings significant to Holyoke's history; encouraging new building designs compatible with the existing architectures; and making the city and owners of properties in such a district eligible for historic-upkeep grants.
The city might even benefit from tourism by establishing a Polish historic district, Mausel said.
Really?
Some people disagree with that. Jean Dietrich, chairwoman of the Finance Committee of Our Lady of the Cross parish, questioned how the city would gain by establishing such a district other than posting a sign identifying the area as historic.
"Big deal," Dietrich said.
What are the arguments of those opposed to the historic district?
They are concerned with the cost and renovation constraints that a historic designation would impose on owners of such properties.
Generally, a property owner can get a new roof, windows, doors and other exterior elements installed without onerous government hurdles.
But properties in a historic district can be renovated only after the Historical Commission reviews to ensure the materials and design of the planned work aligns with the building's historic nature.
Foes say such materials and process can be too costly and time-consuming.
But officials have said such concerns are unfounded "misinformation." The guidelines allow that for each particular renovation, the proposed work will be reviewed on a case-by-case basis, officials said.
In Bishop Mitchell Thomas Rozanski the diocese has its first Polish bishop. Will that help the cause of those who support the Polish historic district?
Hard to say. The Republican and MassLive.com has tried to get an interview with the bishop to get his thoughts on the district proposal, so far without success.
So the Historical Commission compiled the report that forms the basis of the proposed ordinance that the City Council is considering?
No. That report was done by the Fairfield Avenue Local Historic District Commission.
Why that commission?
Despite referencing an entirely different area of the city, the Fairfield Avenue commission explored the Polish historic district details because the panel had experience in such tasks. That came when the street that bears the commission's name in the Highlands Neighborhood to the north was designated historic in 2010.
So what happens now?
The Ordinance Committee will begin debating the plan for the Polish historic district Tuesday.
Will people who attend the meeting be allowed to address the committee?
Probably. The public hearing part of the process is closed. But councilors can vote to suspend the rules and take public comments. It would be hard to imagine councilors facing a packed gallery of constituents -- and voters -- and not letting them speak.
Eventually, the proposal will go before the full City Council for a vote. If the council approves, the measure goes to Mayor Alex B. Morse, whose signature would be required to establish the historic district in the form of an ordinance. Morse has said he would sign it.
If the council rejects the measure, the proposal for a Polish Heritage Historic District dies.
What then?
Then we all wait for the Vatican decision about Mater Dolorosa Church.
Last question: What does "Mater Dolorosa" mean?
Mater Dolorosa is Latin for "sorrowful mother," a reference to the mother of Christ.