The library leaked in February, April, July and August.
HOLYOKE -- Members of the City Council want a building-code inspection done of the Holyoke Public Library where a half dozen leaks occurred this year despite a $14.5 million renovation.
Councilors said Tuesday (Nov. 18) they are unsatisfied with the response of library officials and a contractor about why the facility at 250 Chestnut St. has leaked and how the leaks have been handled a year after reopening following the renovation.
"The key is, who is in charge? I haven't heard from anybody who's in charge," Councilor at Large Joseph M. McGiverin said.
Councilors need to hold a meeting with library officials and someone from Fontaine Bros. General Contractors, of Springfield, which was in charge of the library renovation, McGiverin said.
Maria G. Pagan is the library director and there is a 13-member board of directors.
Finance Committee Chairman Todd A. McGee said the city should get certification that the building is in compliance with building codes after roof and other kinds of leaks had to be repaired.
"That's not how we should be doing business. Send someone up there with a license (to inspect the library). We spent a lot of money up there," McGee said.
He will file an order calling for an inspection at the next council meeting, he said.
The library reopened Nov. 22, 2013 after nearly two years of construction in a renovation prompted in part by years of roof leaks that had damaged the structure and created mold. The renovation featured a 15,000-square-foot addition built onto what was the rear of the original, 111-year-old, 25,000-square-foot library.
The library's entrance now is from Chestnut Street. Previously it fronted on Maple Street.
The renovation was funded with more than $5.5 million in city borrowing, $4.6 million from the Holyoke Public Library Board endowment, a $4.3 million state grant, other grants and fundraising.
The discussion Tuesday came as the council received a report from its Public Safety Committee about the library leaks.
"As we all know, there have been a number of issues following with renovation of the library," committee Chairwoman Linda L. Vacon said.
Some councilors said that despite the issue having been discussed in committee, more questioning of officials is needed.
McGiverin said the library roof leaking so soon after a costly renovation was disturbingly similar to the old police station.
That building opened behind City Hall in 1979 and leaks began almost immediately, leading to years of mold and unhealthy air. Local 388, International Brotherhood of Police Officers took the city to Hampden County Superior Court where a judge ordered construction of a new police headquarters, a $9.7 million facility that opened at 138 Appleton St. in 1997.
McGiverin said he wasn't criticizing Vacon or the Public Safety Committee.
"What I'm criticizing is the lack of response" from library officials, the contractor and the Department of Public Works, McGiverin said.
"I think there's more to it. I think we're slipping, just like we did with the (old) police station...we certainly should have our questions answered," McGiverin said.
Councilor at Large James M. Leahy said he understands that attaching a new building to an old one, as was the case with the library renovation, is difficult. But that's why the renovation cost so much money, he said.
"We had significant leaks in our brand new library," Leahy said.
The first leak was detected in February in the seam where the old and new buildings meet. It caused a small stain on the carpet in the Periodicals Room, library officials said in a memo to councilors in August.
Two more leaks occurred in April. A "design error" led to roof drains being clogged with leaf and maple tree seeds, causing gutters to overflow onto the roof. Water found its way into the building through a crack where the old and new buildings meet, officials said.
The drains were cleaned, the crack was sealed and the ceiling was repaired and painted, officials said.
Another leak occurred in April because a door to one of the heating and cooling machines on the roof was closed improperly, allowing wind and rain into the space and eventually into the building. Such doors have been fastened shut and are supposed to be inspected periodically, officials said in April.
In July, a leak occurred from an air conditioner on the roof into the circulation area of the library. That was because of an "incorrect pitch to the drain pan" on the roof and it was fixed July 21, the library officials' memo said.
In August, what library officials in the memo called a small leak occurred in the History Room "occasioned by horizontal rain due to almost hurricane force winds getting under the louvers of the attic vent and running down the wood trusses from the vented ridge."