Nine votes will again be necessary at the City Council Aug. 20 meeting for final approval of the land transfer.
WESTFIELD - The City Council Thursday night narrowly granted initial approval to the transfer of land on Ponders Hollow Road from the fire to the parks and recreation departments.
The 9-4 vote came after at least six parents of students from the former Juniper Park School, now scheduled for transport to the Russell Elementary School in Russell, made passionate pleas for approval of not only the land swap but also a proposed $36 million new elementary school at Ashley and Cross streets.
Nine affirmative votes by the council were necessary to approve the land transfer and nine votes will again be needed when the issue comes up for final approval at the City Council's Aug. 20 meeting.
An estimated 30 residents, representing the Juniper Park School owned by Westfield State University and no longer used by the School Department, attended the council meeting Thursday.
Several parents who spoke tried to intimidate councilors opposed to the transfer and who have consistently voiced opposition to the location of the new new school at the Ashley and Cross streets site.
Residents reminded City Council members that this is an election year and all, especially the opposition, are up for re-election in November.
One speaker, Leslie Clark Yvon, retired principal of Franklin Avenue School, pleaded with councilors to approve the transfer and move forward with construction of the school that will replace Abner Gibbs and Franklin Avenue schools, both of which are over crowded and suffer from building deficiencies.
One parent called on the council to "provide the same opportunities to students of Abner Gibbs and Franklin Avenue schools that are afforded other students and other schools throughout the city."
The proposed $36 million school, designed to house 600 students in grades kindergarten to grade 5, has already received approval and 68 percent reimbursement by the Massachusetts School Building Authority.
The intent of city and school officials was to use the new school, originally proposed in 2010, to replace the need for the city to lease Juniper Park School and close the aging Abner Gibbs and Franklin Avenue schools.
But, construction of the building has been tied up in Superior Court and now state Appellate Court by some residents of Ashley and Court streets. Their opposition cites the size of the building in a residential neighborhood and anticipated congested traffic flow on both streets.
The land transfer of Ponders Hollow Road parcel will not only move from the Fire Department to the Parks and Recreations but also be used to supplement the loss of the Cross Street Playground if the new school is ever built.
Also, the transfer will allow the Parks and Recreation Department to better maintain the Ponders Hollow parcel and eventually create passive recreation there, city and school officials say.
Council at-Large members David A. Flaherty, Cindy C. Harris, Dan Allie and Ward 4 Councilor Mary L. O'Connell have consistently opposed the land project and school construction.
Harris said Thursday she is awaiting a court resolution to the dispute between residents and the city. Allie, Flaherty and O'Connell have questioned the legality of the land transfer as well as the neighborhood opposition to the school.