Sensitivity training the Holyoke City Council received June 29 is lingering as an election-season issue, complete with name-calling.
HOLYOKE — City Council candidate Mike Franco criticized the sensitivity training that councilors recently received as "iron-fisted...indoctrination," and also aimed a blast at Ward 4 Councilor Jossie M. Valentin.
"Jossie wants all of us to hold hands and talk about her vagina. I say, no thank you," said Franco, according to a June 17 online post.
That was a reference to Valentin helping to direct and produce a Spanish performance on April 18 of "The Vagina Monologues" at the War Memorial, 310 Appleton St.
Franco's comments were posted on the site Meetup.com, which says its mission is to "revitalize local community and help people around the world self-organize."
Franco said on Meetup.com on June 17, above a copy of a Republican / MassLive.com story about city councilors undergoing sensitivity training, "Forced, potentially iron-fisted 'diversity and sensitivity' indoctrination training for our elected officials on Holyoke City Council. And at least one councilor wants it opened to viewing by the public. Make sure you eat your vegetables!"
Valentin said that Franco's comments were unfortunate and that he owed voters an explanation.
"It is unfortunate that a candidate who is running for office would see an inclusive leadership training as 'forced, iron-fisted, indoctrination,' instead of seeing it as an opportunity for personal growth and development to better serve the diverse citizens of Holyoke," Valentin said.
"To refer to this training as 'the Council allowing itself to be bullied' makes no sense to me. In addition, Mr. Franco's choice of words about me is perplexing. I think Mr. Franco owes the voters – especially women – an explanation as to what his intent was with these posts and comments," she said.
In a statement when asked to elaborate (see below), Franco said staging "The Vagina Monologues" at the War Memorial was "blasphemous" and better suited in a city like Northampton.
"First, and most importantly, the building is not an appropriate venue for this play. It is a hallowed ground to honor our nation's veterans and armed forces members," Franco said.
Valentin and other organizers obtained permission from officials to hold "The Vagina Monologues" performance at the site the same way organizers of other events seek such authorization, she said. The $1,150 proceeds from the play went to Womanshelter/Comaneras of Holyoke, which helps victims of domestic violence, she said.
"For him to refer to the 'Monologues' as a 'blasphemous program,' when it is recognized worldwide as a tool to address violence against women, is quite an insult to women, especially those who are victims of violence," Valentin said.
Franco and Valentin are not running against each other in the Nov. 3 election. Franco, who has sought numerous seats in elections over the years, is running for one of the City Council's eight at large seats.
Valentin is seeking election to a second term representing Ward 4.
Twelve of the 15 councilors attended the June 29 training at City Hall on inclusive leadership, sensitivity and diversity. In interviews later, councilors praised the kindness and expertise of the trainers who led the 3½-hour session and said the setting free of scrutiny and politics let councilors talk and be themselves.
The city paid $1,500 for the training that was held in City Council Chambers at City Hall.
Despite the training being paid for with taxpayer funds and held in a public building, the public and press were banned from the session under the part of the state Open Meeting Law that permits elected bodies to gather in a way that won't be considered a "meeting" if the purpose is to attend a "training program ... so long as the members do not deliberate."
Franco said remarks he posts on Meetup.com and sites like Twitter and Facebook are speech protected by the U.S. Constitution's First Amendment.
"So if Ms. Valentin and her people don't like what I have to say on my social media outlets, they don't have to read it. To the contrary, my friends, and those I associate with in the realm of public advocacy tend to like my sites, so I will continue to maintain them as is – philosophically speaking, and expand upon them going forward," Franco said.
The training that "Valentin demanded" the City Council receive was wasted time and money because voters who object to what councilors do or say can vote them out of office, he said.
"Remember, they're elected officials of a legislative body, and not appointees, department heads, and/or civil service where some of these courses may be necessary," Franco said.
Valentin said, "Clearly, Mr. Franco is confused about how this training came about. I guess he did not follow it closely to realize that it was a unanimous vote of the City Council that resulted in this training taking place."
"He is ridiculous," she said.
The training was related to an incident that occurred in City Council Chambers Oct. 1, 2013.
That night, without realizing their microphones were on, Councilors Daniel B. Bresnahan and Todd A. McGee were overheard briefly remarking about the attractiveness of pregnant councilors. It was a reference to Councilor at Large Rebecca Lisi, who was pregnant at the time, and Councilor at Large Brenna Murphy McGee, Todd McGee's wife, who was then a councilor and is now city clerk and who was pregnant the year before. Bresnahan and McGee apologized.
The outcry in the wake of that incident included calls for the City Council to undergo such training.
Here is a statement from Mike Franco responding to criticisms of his remarks on Meetup.com by Ward 4 Councilor Jossie M. Valentin and providing an elaboration on a comment he made about Valentin and the play "The Vagina Monologues:"
"First, my Meetup blog, as well as my Twitter and Facebook pages are social media outlets within my private purview in a public domain. These outlets are not constructed in an official capacity of the City of Holyoke, and each is protected speech under the First Amendment.
"So if Ms. Valentin and her people don't like what I have to say on my social media outlets, they don't have to read it. To the contrary, my friends, and those I associate with in the realm of public advocacy tend to like my sites, so I will continue to maintain them as is - philosophically speaking, and expand upon them going forward.
"Second, it's my view that the training Ms. Valentin demanded members of the city council to perform was unnecessary and wasteful. If constituents and voters don't like how our councilors behave or what they say, intended or not, they can vote them out. Remember, they're elected officials of a legislative body, and not appointees, department heads, and/or civil service where some of these courses may be necessary.
"Furthermore, we're only human and sometime make petty mistakes. I voted for Dan Bresnahan, and would have voted for Todd McGee if he were in my ward notwithstanding Ms. Valentin's judgment. Hence, it is the more ordinary folks who would get my support and vote at the end of the day.
"Also, public monies used for 'feel-good' training for the Council would have been better spent through funding law enforcement programs in the lower wards. Public safety is where the rubber meets the road. This would be a more optimal use of tax dollars, affording a positive and direct impact to quality of life issues in our community.
"Finally, regarding Ms. Valentin hosting the Vagina Monologues in our War Memorial Building I have much to say.. First, and most importantly, the building is not an appropriate venue for this play. It is a hallowed ground to honor our nation's veterans and armed forces members. The push of her personal agenda in a public war memorial is reprehensible, and none other than a 'poke in the eye' to the good and decent people of Holyoke.
"Ms. Valentin could have quickly and easily found the right place in Northampton to host her Vagina Monologues. There are multiple venues for these alternative forms of expression, arts and entertainment. Frankly, I question any city leader who would encourage and allow such a blasphemous program to occur in our War Memorial Building.
Mike Franco"
Here are Ward 4 Councilor Jossie M. Valentin's comments regarding remarks made by City Council candidate Mike Franco:
"It is unfortunate that a candidate who is running for office would see an inclusive leadership training as 'forced, iron-fisted, indoctrination,' instead of seeing it as an opportunity for personal growth and development to better serve the diverse citizens of Holyoke. To refer to this training as 'the Council allowing itself to be bullied' makes no sense to me. In addition, Mr. Franco's choice of words about me is perplexing. I think Mr. Franco owes the voters -- especially women -- an explanation as to what his intent was with these posts and comments.
"It's also hilarious that he thinks I mandated the training. He is clearly unfamiliar with how the Council works and how orders are filed and voted on. The order that resulted in the training moving forward was filed by Kevin (City Council President Kevin A. Jourdain) and Rebecca (Lisi). I wasn't even a cosponsor of it.
"Clearly, Mr. Franco is confused about how this training came about. I guess he did not follow it closely to realize that it was a unanimous vote of the city council that resulted in this training taking place.
"In terms of his ridiculous statement about the 'Vagina Monologues,' the 'Monologues' were put together by a group of Holyoke community members. We went through the process of meeting with the War Memorial commissioners to present the project and obtain their authorization. This was not a random request from me as a city councilor.
"For him to refer to the monologues as a 'blasphemous program,' when it is recognized worldwide as a tool to address violence against women, is quite an insult to women, especially those who are victims of violence.
"He is ridiculous."