"They talked about a Mercedes and they're giving us a Cadillac," City Councilor Bud Williams said at a recent candidates forum, by way of criticizing MGM Springfield.
SPRINGFIELD — Eight of the 10 at-large candidates for Springfield City Council attended Thursday evening's election forum at Classical Condominiums, where they talked casinos, crime and the difficulty of drawing new blood to Springfield.
The candidates' forum was hosted by the Armoury-Quadrangle Civic Association and emceed by Carol Costa, the group's president, who introduced the participants and asked a series of prepared questions.
Before the competitors for five citywide council seats had a chance to speak their piece, the two candidates running for the Ward 1 seat – incumbent Zaida Luna and challenger Adam Gomez – staked out their positions before a crowd in the condo's ornate atrium.
MGM's leaner version of its original casino plan invoked some of the strongest feelings of the night, particularly from incumbents Bud Williams, Kateri Walsh and Justin Hurst, all of whom have voiced concerns about the project after the casino company scrapped plans for a high-rise hotel in Springfield.
Walsh said she was "disturbed" when the project's "wow factor" – a 25-story, glass-facade hotel – was cut from the plan. City leaders are also worried about the 14 percent reduction in the project's overall size. Walsh claimed MGM had blindsided and embarrassed "our mayor," referring to Mayor Domenic Sarno. "There are significant changes – less parking, less retail," she said.
City Councilor Kateri Walsh, shown here in a file photo from The Republican, criticized MGM's handling of the downsized casino project. Republican photo by Mark Murray
Williams offered a blunter assessment of the changes. "Shame on MGM. Shame on MGM," he said. "They talked about a Mercedes and they're giving us a Cadillac," he said. "Or a Chevy."
It's time for city leaders to consider all options, according to Williams. "Maybe we should talk about an exit strategy," he said, adding that he doesn't trust MGM.
"Bottom line is we need to hold MGM accountable," Councilor Hurst said. "I agree with Bud that we need to have an exit strategy," he said.
Concerns raised by the five challengers – LaMar Cook, Jeffery Donnelly, Jesse Lederman, Kenneth Pooler and Alex Sherman – ranged from faulting MGM to criticizing city leaders for not doing their homework on the proejct.
Cook said Springfield voters are not getting the plan they voted for, while Lederman said MGM should be held accountable for scaling back the plan, especially the entertainment and retail components.
Pooler never believed MGM would build its project in Springfield, he said, knocking city leaders for "flip-flopping" on the issue. Sherman said local officials should have taken a more proactive approach with MGM from the get-go.
Donnelly voiced support for MGM's plan to replace the 25-story hotel tower with a six-story structure, saying the shorter building is more in scale with the city's history. "The way it was before, it was just a giant billboard for MGM," he said, referring to the high-rise component.
However, Donnelly doesn't support shrinking the project's square-footage by 14 percent, a move he said was "uncalled for."
Springfield City Councilor Bud Williams, shown here in a file photo from The Republican, said MGM should be ashamed of itself for ill communication.File photo by Manon Mirabelli
When the discussion shifted to crime in the city, the candidates said they support the current community-policing tactics and various trust-building measures the department has implemented under the stewardship of Springfield Police Commissioner John Barbieri.
Williams said the community walks he's participated in with Barbieri and others have helped "tear down the barriers" between police officers and the people they police in Springfield's tougher neighborhoods, where trust has long been issue. "At the end of the day, we're one city, one people," Williams said.
Springfield police officers do a great job, but there needs to be a "balanced effort" between cops, citizens and city leaders, according to Cook.
Donnelly believes police officers are "doing the best job they can," but they shouldn't be walking around the city as "code enforcement officers," he said.
Springfield needs to hire more officers and get more cops walking beats and interacting with people, according to Lederman.
Pooler is a strong advocate of fighting blight – "Vacant lots lead to crime," he said – and adding police substations to troubled sections of the city. "We need to rekindle the relationship between the Police Department and our youths," he said.
Walsh and Hurst both praised Barbieri for doing a good job. "I think we're in very good hands with Commissioner Barbieri," Walsh said, citing his embrace of technology to fight crime. Hurst said Barbieri has "done a very good job" of building relationships between officers and the community, crediting C3 and other community-policing initiatives.
Justin Hurst, a Springfield City Councilor running for re-election, attended Thursday evening's candidates forum at Classical Condominiums, where he said the city should consider an exit strategy from MGM.
Facebook
On the issue of where city employees should live, most of the candidates generally supported the idea of a residency requirement.
"If you work for the city, you should live here – plain and simple," Donnelly said, singling out city cops and firefighters in particular.
It's a "no-brainer" that teachers and public safety workers should live in the city, enhancing the tax base, said Cook.
Lederman said he supports residency requirements for anyone who collects a paycheck from the city and creating incentives for other municipal employees who are not required to live within the city limits to consider that option.
Hurst agreed that Springfield needs to become a more attractive place to live, so young professionals and others "want to come here."
Williams said the city has been too lax on the residency issue. "We have not been tough enough on residency. We need to get tougher," he said.
Incumbent city councilors Tim Rooke and Tom Ashe did not attend the candidates' forum.