Incoming interim director Cheryl Lussier Poppe was praised by a member of the Holyoke Soldiers' Home board of trustees.
HOLYOKE -- The two-hour-plus meeting at the Holyoke Soldiers' Home about the leadership turnover yielded a cargo of issues and comments.
Here are five takeaways from the Wednesday session of the facility's board of trustees that drew veterans, families, staff and state officials to the 110 Cherry St. Holyoke Soldiers' Home:
1. Procedure: Who had authority to make decisions on certain points was fluid depending on which official was speaking.
Steven E. Como, chairman of the board of trustees, began the meeting by reading a letter dated Monday from Gov. Charlie Baker to the trustees. Baker said he is appointing Cheryl Lussier Poppe, superintendent of the Chelsea Soldiers' Home, interim director of the Holyoke Soldiers' Home while a search committee is formed to find a permanent superintendent.
That committee will recommend superintendent candidates for Baker's approval. That was the process that former Gov. Deval L. Patrick used in 2011 to appoint current Superintendent Paul Barabani, Baker said.
Barabani announced Dec. 15 he would retire in January and expanded on the reasons on Wednesday when he said state officials have failed to approve funding, staff and other steps necessary to care for the facility's veterans.
"I've been given a mission but I haven't been given the resources to accomplish that mission," Barabani said.
Deputy Superintendent Paradis submitted a resignation letter the next day, effective Jan. 1, saying he would work there only with Barabani as superintendent.
Como also had resigned on Dec. 15, saying that after eight years it was simply time and he wanted to give Baker an opportunity to appoint his own chairman. But Como said Wednesday he will stay on until Baker appoints a replacement.
Trustees board member Daniel J. Smith objected after Como read Baker's letter. The trustees, and not Baker, should be deciding on an interim leader of the Holyoke Soldiers' Home, he said.
"I respectfully disagree with the governor," Smith said.
Calls were voiced to have counsel weigh in, "Our counsel," said Smith, referring to board lawyer Donald R. Andrejczyk.
But Como said that since the group of state officials attending the meeting included Jesse M. Caplan, general counsel for the Executive Office of Health and Human Services, he could go first.
State law is clear that the Holyoke Soldiers' Home and the board of trustees are supervised by the governor, Caplan said.
Also, Caplan said that Baker noted in his letter that Poppe will be not the interim superintendent but interim director of the Holyoke Soldiers' Home.
"I certainly feel it's within his authority," Caplan said.
Andrejczyk stepped to the microphone and disagreed, citing Chapter 6, Section 71 of Massachusetts General Laws.
"The trustees appoint the superintendent," Andrejczyk said.
Trustee Brian Q. Corridan said the board should take a vote on whether Poppe will be interim head of the facility.
"I do think at least to protect the integrity of this board that the board should at least vote on that," Corridan said.
Como said that was prohibited during that particular meeting under the Open Meeting Law because the agenda posted 48 hours in advance of the session lacked notice to the public that such a vote would take place.
Yet another procedural issue arose later in the meeting. Amid calls for Barabani to stay on, Corridan asked Barabani if such a door was still open.
Barabani said he doubted state officials would meet his conditions. But he said such conditions would be that: the board of trustees unanimously vote to support him; that he be allowed to make decisions to run the facility; and that a concrete plan be established to increase staff, including filling positions such as a chief financial officer and a community outreach officer.
A top state official who attended the meeting confirmed that was unlikely to happen. The governor and the board of trustees have accepted Barabani's resignation and the state is moving forward with finding a successor, said Francisco A. Urena, secretary of the state Department of Veterans Services.
But, Barabani said, it was a retirement he has planned, not a resignation, and he had yet to submit his retirement papers for separation from the state.
2. Plug for Poppe:
Board member Margaret E. Oglesby added some levity, in praising Barabani, and perspective to the meeting.
"If I had my way, I would handcuff Paul to the building, but I think that would be kidnapping," Oglesby said.
Oglesby has served in the Massachusetts National Guard, including earning a Bronze Star in Afghanistan. Poppe served 30 years in the National Guard, according to Baker's letter.
"She was on the other end of the phone when I was in Afghanistan....She will do a good job," Oglesby said.
3. Life-saving care:
Residents and families described the loving care veterans receive from Holyoke Soldiers' Home staff.
After the meeting, Martha Murphy, 66, who said she has her own serious health issues, spoke to The Republican and MassLive.com about her husband Daniel Murphy, 67, an Air Force veteran living at the Soldiers' Home.
The exertion of trying to care for her husband while suffering her own declining health nearly killed her, she said, and the burden largely lifted thanks to the Soldiers' Home staff.
"They're here day and night. I have gotten calls from them at 11:30 p.m. just to make sure they are checking in. They were doing this to relieve me, which affects my well-being....I'm still alive because of the care he receives," Murphy said.
4. Labor issues?
Mark DelloRusso, president of Service Employees International Union Local 888, which represents most employees at the Holyoke Soldiers' Home, said in an email Tuesday that problems have included labor contract violations, lack of respect for workers and intimidation can be added to the leadership issues at the Holyoke Soldiers' Home.
"Given the litany of issues our members have brought to our attention, it seems a change in management is long overdue," DelloRusso said in the email.
Reading a copy of The Republican and MassLive.com news story, Barabani led with that during the meeting in his first of several turns with the microphone.
He read aloud DelloRusso's criticisms.
"Do you believe that?" Barabani said to the crowd, prompting a loud "No."
"I respect my staff and everybody knows that. There are no contract violations. What you have is a small" part of staff objecting to responsibilities, he said.
"As Bill Belichick says, just do your job," Barabani said.
5. The legislators were there:
Easy to pick out as the guys in suits kind of clustering together, and as members of an institution even more easy to scoff at -- politicians -- it perhaps merits saying that legislators who represent local districts on Beacon Hill showed up to support the Holyoke Soldiers' Home.
State Sen. Donald R. Humason, R-Westfield, state Rep. Aaron M. Vega, D-Holyoke, state Rep. Carlos Gonzalez, D-Springfield, and state Rep. John Velis, D-Westfield, a captain in the U.S. Army Reserves, made remarks during the meeting.
"At the end of the day, politics aside, it's about the veterans," Velis said.