Police seized computers, documents and files during a warrant search on Saturday at the private school in Great Barrington that serves boys 9 to 22 who have cognitive and developmental disabilities including autism and Asperger's Syndrome.
GREAT BARRINGTON — Amid charges of abuse of three students by staff, officials with Eagleton School said the reputation and the mission of the school are being damaged but the truth will eventually come out.
Officials, legal council and even some parents of children at the Great Barrington private academy spoke at a press conference Wednesday to defend the school and to say the allegations are in no way representative of the work that goes on there.
Eagleton founder Bruce Bona said that in its 35 years, Eagleton has "changed lives and made a difference" for hundreds of troubled children. The residential school was founded in 1977 and serves boys ages 9 to 22 who have cognitive and developmental disabilities including autism and Asperger's Syndrome.
"The 160 staff work to put their hearts and souls out to those children," he said.
Eagleton made the news over the weekend with the announcement by the Berkshire County District Attorney's Office that federal, state and local law enforcement executed a search warrant on the school Saturday night, and arrested five staff members.
Accompanying law enforcement were staff with the state Department of Early Education and Care who were present to care for the remaining students and to continue operations of the school.
Berkshire District Attorney David F. Capeless said the warrant was part of an investigation into allegations of physical and emotional abuse of students by school staff.
According to Eagleton officials, law enforcement seized computers and servers, documents and files.
Arrested were Brian Puntin, 47, of Lenoxdale, Peter Meadow, 51, of Lenox, James Swift, 54, of Pittsfield, Juan Pablo Lopez-Lucas, 34, of Pittsfield, and Debra Davis, 41, of Great Barrington.
All five work in the school's autism center.
Meadow, Puntin and Swift were each charged with a single count of assault and battery on a disabled person, and Lopez-Lucas was charged with one count of assault and battery with a dangerous weapon and one count of assault and battery on a disabled person. Davis was charged with intimidation of a witness and obstruction of justice.
At their arraignments in Central Berkshire Court on Monday, each denied the charges and was released without bail on the condition they keep away from the school and any students. All five are due back in court on March 10 for a pre-trial hearing.
All five are on a paid suspension, the school said.
Roderick MacLeish, a Boston attorney representing the school, defended the school, its staff and its existing protocols. The staff are highly trained in dealing with students with emotional problems, he said.
The school as recently as October was giving a successful review by the state Department of Education, he said.
He bristled at a description offered by the Berkshire District Attorney's Office that the situation at the school was "terrible."
MacLeish said, "I'm not sure what he meant by that, but we're here today to talk about the other side of the Eagleton School that is not terrible."
He said the school has an international reputation for helping children with several learning and emotional disabilities. It has an enrollment of 75 students from 12 states. It has 160 dedicated staff, and reports to three separate state agencies.
There was no interruption of services after the police action, and the school is still accepting new students.
"We're doing out best to keep the students out of this," MacLeish said.
He also said he was upset with media coverage, both locally and nationally as well as internationally since the warrant search.
He also singled out the Berkshire Eagle for a headline reading "A terrible situation."
"That was reprinted around the United States and Great Britain. Eagleton is not a place where there is a terrible situation," he said.
"This is America. We live in a place where people are entitled to ... both sides getting heard. What is happening across the country, with the frenzy and the accusations across the country, is something that is enormously distressing," the attorney said.
All of the accused are daytime staff, charged with abuse of three students in the autism unit.
MacLeish emphasized that point repeatedly – that the reported assaults are said to have occurred in the daytime and were not "a nighttime thing."
Four staffers are accused of assault or assault with a dangerous weapon. One is accused of tampering with video equipment and transferring someone to a new unit to avoid the reporting of wrongdoing.
The assault with a dangerous weapon charges involve someone being kicked with a shod foot and being hit against a picnic table.
The three students remain enrolled at the school.
MacLeish cautioned against people reading too much into the charges, saying that they are allegations at this point, and the people accused still need their day in court. He pledged the school will cooperate fully with the district attorney, and any state agencies. The school also is conducting its own internal investigation.
The school is equipped with video surveillance systems in common areas, and he said the video is being reviewed as part of the investigation.
The warrant search on Saturday was triggered by the school in January reporting an allegation that a staff member slapped a student. The staff member in question is one of the five who were arrested.
He said he did not know if that allegation was true or not, but the school reported it just as it is supposed to do according to internal protocols and state regulations.
The school is "intensely regulated" by state agencies and he emphasized that since the allegations arose, "there has been no regulatory action against the Eagleton School by the people who know it best. I want to make that clear."
Three parents of past and present students spoke at the press conference to defend the school and to swear by the work that staff there have done to aid their children. Each of the parents identified themselves only by first name in order to maintain privacy.
One man named Mike said his son attended the school for 18 months for treatment of several emotional issues. He credited the school with saving his son's life, restoring his family and giving them all hope for the future. Thanks to the school, his son is now enrolled in a regular high school, he said.
Mike said he heard about the allegations on Wednesday and drove up from New Jersey to show his support. "All of this ridiculousness that's going on on the Internet, and all these stories is the reason I'm here today. It's ridiculous," he said.
A woman named Caroline said her son is enrolled in the school and he is "happy, content and hopeful for his future."
Mass DOE review of Eagleton School, 2015 by Patrick Johnson