While the connections between the suspects and victims remain unclear, court documents reveal that both victims Mark Greenlaw and Jennifer O'Connor had run-ins with the law more than once.
The mysterious killings at 19 Farm Ave. on Saturday continue to be just that: a mystery. Authorities have not explained how Mark Greenlaw, 37, and Jennifer O'Connor, 39, died, only that their dismembered remains were found in the home's basement. Two suspects have been identified: Michael Hebb, 45, who was arrested Monday and will be held without bail on two counts of first-degree murder, and Wes Doughty, 39, who is still at large.
Peabody murder suspect Wes Doughty allegedly stole car, took man from Middleton to Boston
While the connections between the suspects and victims remain unclear, court documents reveal that both Greenlaw and O'Connor had repeated run-ins with the law.
Murder suspect Michael Hebb did not have an extensive criminal past. Most recently, in March 2016, police reports say Hebb was caught driving with a suspended license near 19 Farm Ave., the site of the killings.
Michael Hebb arrested in connection with Peabody double homicide; Other suspect still at large
No immediate relatives of Greenlaw have spoken out about the disturbing police findings at the Peabody home, but one distant in-law said she knew him as a good person. "He was protective of his siblings and mom," said the woman, who only provided her first name, Pam.
"He was friendly, he was kind of hyper, jumping around, happy," she told reporters after the arraignment of suspect Michael Hebb. Pam said Greenlaw was her grandson's uncle by marriage.
She said she hadn't seen Greenlaw in nearly six months, and that she loved the family. "He was very much loved," she added.
Greenlaw, born in Malden to Margaret Bollettiero and Murry Greenlaw, attended the Veterans Memorial High School in Peabody, where he spent much of his adult life.
The 37-year-old worked in construction in the Greater Boston area. Greenlaw covered his body in tattoos, most notably the phrase "White Power" inked across his chest, below a Celtic knot. Greenlaw's supremacist tattoo is mentioned in court documents.
The parents of Jennifer O'Connor have been vocal that their daughter had a good heart and struggled with drug addiction. The 39-year-old reportedly suffered health problems throughout her life, including leukemia in her early childhood, and that her problems with drugs and alcohol began after she was prescribed narcotics following medical treatment.
'Drugs did her in,' mother of Peabody homicide victim Jennifer O'Connor says of her daughter
While there are many unanswered questions surrounding their deaths, it's clear that both Greenlaw and O'Connor had histories with police and drugs.
Court files referred to Greenlaw as a "career criminal" involved in various criminal offenses. Greenlaw was out on $1,000 cash bail at the time of his death, for allegedly threatening and harassing a woman. He spent time in prison for a robbery and a firearms offense, and some court files show he followed a path of drug-fueled violence.
Less than a year ago in July 2016, Greenlaw was accused of verbally threatening a woman, who then filed a criminal complaint against him. Greenlaw allegedly screamed "You're dead" to the woman, while leaning out of the window of a pick-up truck. She told police that Greenlaw was angry she did not let him into her home several weeks earlier. At that time, in July 2016, Greenlaw also had an active warrant out of Peabody District Court for a robbery and an assault and battery.
A separate violent incident against his sister prompted Greenlaw's mother to tell police her son needed to be in a drug program, according to police reports. In April 2015, police responded to an apartment on Lowell Street in Peabody, where his sister reported being punched in the head. Greenlaw told police his sister owed him $300, and that he had taken four Xanax pills and was off his medication. His mother, Margo Duarte, told police her son had actually ingested nine Xanax pills.
Duarte said her son became very violent when he did not take his medication, which a police report indicates was taken to help ease an addiction to heroin. Greenlaw was arrested on charges of assault and battery against a family member.
Last year, drugs, police, and the lives of Mark Greenlaw and Jennifer O'Connor converged in a Peabody basement. Mark Greenlaw called police for a medical emergency: Jennifer O'Connor had overdosed on drugs. Police found O'Connor unresponsive in the basement of a home on North End Street, and she was taken by ambulance to Salem Hospital.
Earlier that year, in January, a police report describes the scene when O'Connor crashed her car and was unable to pass a sobriety test. She was charged with operating under the influence for a second time. A month later, court documents say O'Connor failed a random pre-trial drug screening.
When her case went to Peabody District Court, the judge, defendant and prosecutor all agreed that charges of negligent operation be dismissed. The agreed condition meant O'Connor would have to go two years as drug-free and alcohol-free, with random screenings.
As of Thursday morning, five days after the body parts were discovered, murder suspect Wes Doughty was still at large. Police say he carjacked a man in Middleton and drove all the way into Boston before stopping at a liquor store, where the victim managed to escape.