Day two in the manhunt for a social services worker from the Greater Cleveland area accused of gunning down a 74-year-old stranger and then posting a gruesome video of the deed on Facebook ended with almost no new clues in the wanted man's whereabouts.
Watch video
Steve StephensFacebook
Robert GodwinSubmitted
CLEVELAND, Ohio -- Day two in the manhunt for a social services worker from the Greater Cleveland area accused of gunning down a 74-year-old stranger and then posting a gruesome video of the deed on Facebook ended with almost no new clues in the wanted man's whereabouts.
Monday came and went with no signs of Steve Stephens, 37, in a search that expanded from the states that border Ohio to a nationwide search for the man wanted in Robert Godwin Sr.'s death. On Monday, Stephens became one of the FBI's Most Wanted.
The only significant lead was a false alarm, as several people called 911 to say they saw Stephens in a public park in Philadelphia.
By Monday afternoon, local officials offered up a $50,000 reward in the hope that it would shake loose any information about Stephens' whereabouts. In the day since his disappearance, Stephens eluded state, local and federal authorities. He is wanted on a warrant charging him with aggravated murder, and authorities say they are now searching for his car, a white 2016 Ford Fusion that he purchased this month, that has all but vanished from the public eye.
"Our reach now is basically all over this country," police Chief Calvin Williams said at a news conference Monday afternoon. "This is what we would consider a national search for Steve. So we are not going to leave any stone unturned."
What stoked fears of ordinary citizens who have followed the details of the case through social media and news outlets is the arbitrary nature of the killing. Stephens selected his victim seemingly at random as the retired foundry worker looked for scrap aluminum cans along East 93rd Street in the city's Glenville neighborhood, filmed the shooting and posted it on Facebook, police said.
In the video, Stephens approached Godwin and made him say the name of his own estranged girlfriend. The demand puzzled Godwin, who was shot at almost point-blank range with a pistol.
Stephens also claimed in subsequent Facebook video posts that he "snapped," he killed more people and would continue to do so. Police have found no evidence linking him to any other homicides despite the churning rumor mill of amateur sleuths who have taken to social media in a cycle of endless speculation.
Facebook shuttered Stephens' account Sunday, and on Monday the social media company announced it was reviewing the way users can report videos and how administrators can address policy violations. Sunday's shooting is the latest in a long and growing stream of crimes broadcast via social media.
Godwin's family spent Monday grieving and making funeral preparations. A group including Godwin's loved ones and well-wishers gathered for a vigil Monday evening at the site of his killing. The Cleveland Cavaliers also paused for a moment of silence before the team's playoff game against the Indiana Pacers Monday night.
Multiple Ohio elected officials also issued statements of concern for Cleveland residents and support for Cleveland police.
Leaving behind multiple children and grandchildren, daughter Debbie Godwin described Robert Godwin Sr. as a caring father who gave his children an admirable work ethic. He had patience and humility and was not easily embarrassed, she said.
"He would go and buy our private things with pride," Debbie Godwin said of her father's attention to her and her sisters. "He had five daughters. He had no shame in his game."
She, along with her brother, said they have no plans to watch the gruesome video.
Stephens at work
As authorities continued their search, a clearer picture emerged Monday of Stephens and his past.
Stephens has been employed at the Pepper Pike-based Beech Brook since 2008, where he most recently worked as a vocational specialist for the facility's Assertive Community Treatment team for kids and young adults, according to a statement from the youth social services organization.
Beech Brook was closed Monday as a result of the manhunt. Its statement said, "we were shocked and horrified yesterday to learn about the situation involving the threats by Steve Stephens and the tragic shooting of Mr. Godwin. Our hearts go out to his family during this time of grief."
Joy Lane, Stephens' girlfriend and a former Beech Brook social worker, was taken into protective custody Sunday and is cooperating with investigators, a law enforcement source said.
She released a text message statement to CBS News early Monday saying she and Stephens had dated for several years and that "I am sorry that all of this has happened." She then went on to describe her boyfriend's good qualities.
"My heart & prayers goes out to the family members of the victim(s)," the text message read, according to CBS. "Steve really is a nice guy... he is generous with everyone he knows. He was kind and loving to me and my children. This is a very difficult time for me and my family Please respect our privacy at this time."
Stephens' financial trouble
Stephens was described by others who knew him as a funny and quiet man. He had almost no criminal history outside of a handful of traffic infractions.
However, his financial troubles are far more serious.
Court records show Stephens declared bankruptcy in 2015 and has faced lawsuits from several creditors seeking to collect payments on credit card debt and rent. In January, he was evicted from his Euclid apartment.
Stephens also detailed his affinity for gambling in one of his multiple Facebook posts, stating that gambling had caused him to "lose everything" and left him "out of options."
"The past year's been really [expletive] up for me," Stephens said in a video, shortly before police said he killed Godwin. "You know, being with [his ex-girlfriend] drove me crazy, started making me gamble. I lost everything. I lost everything I have. I don't have [expletive]. I'm out of options."
Stephens spent at least part of his childhood living at a house on East 85th Street in Cleveland. Neighbors who knew him then said Stephens did not make much of an impression, other than when he would walk outside with a large pet snake wrapped around his neck.
"As he got older, he got a little more weird, just his mannerisms and the way he carried himself," neighbor Tony Henderson said.
Police had stationed themselves Monday afternoon near the house where he grew up, as his mother still lives there.
Stevens, who had a valid concealed carry permit, also recently frequented a gun range in Willoughby, the range owner said.
'As fast as possible'
Officials made it clear Monday that they will continue their expansive search for Stephens. At this point, the U.S. Marshals Service, FBI and Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives are aiding Cleveland police.
"We definitely want to get it resolved as fast as possible," Williams, the Cleveland police chief, said at a news conference. "The victim's family, they deserve that. And the community deserves it."
Williams said earlier in the day that detectives spoke to Stephens on Sunday but have not been able to contact him since. Law enforcement sources said Sunday that Stephens had shut off his phone, thus making it harder to track him.
The police chief cautioned against people trying to take advantage of Godwin's death, noting that several accounts soliciting donations in the family's name on GoFundMe were not sanctioned by the family. However, the company did confirm that there is one official account where donations are being taken.
Case Western Reserve University also came under fire Monday for not notifying students about the shooting and manhunt until hours after other universities and hospitals had addressed them.
The university is reviewing its response to "consider what changes are necessary to ensure more timely action in the future," it said in a statement. Students plan to demonstrate on Tuesday because of the late notification.
The sense of unease stretched far beyond Cleveland, though. On Monday afternoon, multiple people called Philadelphia police to report a sighting of him in the city's largest public park.
The reports led authorities there to lock down nine schools as they searched the area, but later said in a tweet that "at this time, there is no indication that the subject is at that location, or anywhere in the city of Philadelphia."
Cleveland.com reporters Courtney Astolfi, Emily Bamforth, Sara Dorn, Karen Farkas, Adam Ferrise, Stephen Koff, Pete Krouse, Jane Morice, Joe Noga, Cory Shaffer and Andrew J. Tobias contributed to this story.