City officials cited an exemption to the state's Public Records Law that allows for the withholding of information during active investigations.
Watch video
WEST SPRINGFIELD -- The Town of West Springfield has denied The Republican's request for audio dispatch records from the morning of April 23, when Jeremy Edward Hollins was fired on by police after allegedly trying to run down officers in his car while fleeing an attempted traffic stop.
But in the absence of audio records from West Springfield police, The Republican analyzed available dispatch archives from other police agencies, including the Westfield Police Department and Massachusetts State Police. These records provide some details of the timeline of the search for Hollins and the aftermath of the officer-involved shooting.
Officers opened fire on Hollins, 29, of South Tallyho Drive, Springfield, after he rammed police cruisers with his Lexus and injured three officers, according to Hampden District Attorney Anthony Gulluni's office, which is investigating the police shooting.
Hollins abandoned his damaged car near the Wentworth Estates condo complex off Memorial Avenue and fled on foot. When police later found him hiding in a doorway, he allegedly charged at officers, who shot him once in the leg and twice in the shoulder.
A review of the newspaper's request for the West Springfield dispatches, which was made through the state's Public Records Law, determined that the police dispatch records were "exempt from disclosure ... as they relate to an ongoing investigation," said Kate R. O'Brien, town attorney for West Springfield, citing provisions of Massachusetts General Law supporting the decision to deny the request.
The denial makes it difficult to determine a precise timeline of events leading up to two apparent rounds of gunfire during the early morning hours of April 23. The first round occurred around 1 a.m., when Hollins allegedly rammed cruisers with his car and drove straight at officers. The second occurred about 40 minutes later, when Hollins allegedly ran toward officers, prompting them to open fire and wound him.
The Westfield police and Massachusetts State Police records reviewed by The Republican indicate that state police first issued a BOLO (be on the lookout) shortly after 1 a.m.
"From B3, just involved in a shooting with West Springfield police. And also rammed several (West) Springfield police cruisers," the audio clip states. The license plate number for the Lexus is then announced over police radio channels, warning officers to be on the lookout for a "single black male."
"Use caution," the audio states. "Involved in a shooting in West Springfield."
The vehicle's registration was traced to 9 Lakewood Trail in the Fiskdale section of Sturbridge, which is the home address of Hollins' father, James Hollins.
A Westfield police dispatch transmission a short time later provides more details about the shooting: "Dispatch to all units. This is a BOLO from state PD in Springfield. ... Vehicle is wanted by West Springfield for a shooting. Also rammed some cruisers in the process of fleeing, injuring multiple officers. Should be operated by a black male in his 20s or his 30s. If located use caution, stop, hold, notify West Springfield."
At about 1:14 a.m., state police provide further information: "Attention cruisers, a 2015 Lexus sedan, color black. The operator, a black male, Jeremy Hollins, born in '87, 9 Lakewood Trail in Fiskdale. Again, a 2015 Lexus. I have 350 sedan, black."
By roughly 1:18 a.m., a state police transmission indicates authorities "may have located that vehicle, abandoned." A minute later, state police say "the operator is still outstanding. Again, that vehicle has been located."
Around 1:44 a.m., a conversation between troopers is broadcast over the radio: "Sir, unknown if there's any other suspects," one voice says. "They believe this is the only one, although they said they're uncertain as if there may be more."
A second voice responds: "OK, I'm just trying to ascertain if he fits the description of the driver from that car." The answer, from the first voice: "He appears to. It's a black male in his 20s."
In a broadcast around 1:45 a.m., Hollins has been shot and wounded. State police are apparently on scene with West Springfield police, awaiting the arrival of an ambulance from the West Springfield Fire Department.
Again, troopers are heard communicating via radio: "Affirmative, I heard West Springfield advise two minutes out. They should be there any moment now." A second voice responds: "OK, just confirm; we're all tied up here, putting gauze on him and administering aid."
Around 1:46 a.m., the following state police transmission was heard:
First voice: "Two, directly up here, please. ASAP."
Second voice: "Stand by. [Inaudible] of blood on our hands."
Police found two bags of cocaine and a semi-automatic handgun when they searched the Lexus, according to Jim Leydon, spokesman for the district attorney. Hollins was the legal owner of the gun, Leydon said.
Hollins was unarmed at the time of the shooting, according to online statements by his family. The gun found in his car was "properly secured as required by law," they said.
Investigators seized some four dozen items from the damaged car and the debris field it left on the grassy area where it came to rest. These items ranged from clothing and personal electronics to a duffel bag and sex toys, according to a police report.
The Republican has reached out to members of the Hollins family, who have declined to comment or have not returned emails or phone messages. On Friday, James Hollins would not discuss his son's physical condition or criminal case. "You need to talk to our attorney," he said.
Jeremy Hollins grew up in Agawam and lives in Springfield's Sixteen Acres neighborhood.
He has been charged with attempted murder, drunken driving, and other crimes in connection with the April 23 incident in West Springfield. On April 26, he was arraigned in his hospital room at Baystate Medical Center, where Springfield District Court Judge John Payne ordered him to be held on $10,000 cash bail.
Hollins' wife, Shereese Monete Rodgers-Hollins, is listed as "organizer" of a YouCaring page to help defray medical and other expenses related to her husband's injuries. The online fundraising page had raised almost $1,600 by Monday morning.
"Jeremy has finally made it out of ICU and is doing well," the Hollins family said in a message posted on the YouCaring page Friday. The damage to his shoulder and leg is "extensive and will require many hours of physical therapy, additional surgeries, and continued medical care so that he can one day walk again," the message said.
Meanwhile, Rodgers-Hollins has apparently filed for divorce in Hampden Probate and Family Court. The "domestic relations" case, filed April 13, lists Hollins as the defendant and Rodgers-Hollins as the plaintiff. Judge Anne M. Geoffrion has been assigned to the case, which remains "active," according to online records.