Dylan Riel, 4, and Jayce Garcia, 1, both of Southbridge, were killed in a car crash June 20, 2104, in Brimfield in which Suzanne Hardy is charged with manslaughter.
SPRINGFIELD -- The prosecution rested late Tuesday afternoon in the involuntary manslaughter trial of Suzanne Hardy, who is charged in connection with a 2014 Brimfield car crash that killed two brothers.
Two of Hardy's passengers, Dylan Riel, 4, and Jayce Garcia, 1, both of Southbridge, were killed.
Hardy, 24, of Holland, is on trial on two counts of involuntary manslaughter and two counts of motor vehicle homicide by negligent operation for the crash on Route 20 on June 20, 2014, at about 4:45 p.m. She can be found guilty of either manslaughter or motor vehicle homicide, but not both.
She is also charged with two counts of reckless endangerment of a child for not properly securing Jayce and Dylan in the back seat.
Hardy was Dylan's aunt; her brother was Dylan's father.
Dr. Mindy Hull, a state medical examiner who performed the autopsies, testified Tuesday in Hampden Superior Court that both little boys died from similar injuries -- blunt force trauma to the head and neck with differing degrees of separation of the spinal column from the skull base. The injury is most typically caused by the body stopping but the head continuing to move forward, she said.
Dr. Andrew Marino, an emergency room physician at Harrington Hospital in Southbridge, where the boys were first brought, described efforts first to get Jayce's heart going again.
When it became clear that would be unsuccessful, he left staff with Jayce and turned his efforts to Dylan, because Dylan had been brought out of cardiac arrest.
At the time a helicopter took Dylan to UMass Memorial Medical Center, he had a heartbeat and blood pressure, Marino said. Dylan was pronounced dead there.
The rest of the day Tuesday consisted of testimony by Sgt. Christopher Sanchez of the Massachusetts State Police collision analysis and reconstruction section.
Defense lawyer Joan Williams is expected to call her expert witness when testimony resumes at 10 a.m. Wednesday.
Judge Richard J. Carey told jurors that, after the defense expert's testimony, closing arguments and his instructions on the law, he expects they will get the case for deliberations Wednesday.
Hardy until late Tuesday had faced a third count of reckless endangerment of a child, with the allegation being that she did not secure her own 4-year-old child properly in the car. Carey dropped that charge after Williams argued there was testimony Hardy's son was in a booster seat. All three children were in the back seat.
The prosecution contends the involuntary manslaughter charge is based on Hardy's reckless driving and her failure to secure Dylan and Jayce.
Testimony was that the crash happened as Hardy was driving east on Route 20. A Babe's Lawn Care truck was in the left lane eastbound waiting to turn into the company headquarters at 345 Sturbridge Road (Route 20). Hardy went to the right, clipped the guardrail, spun out of control into the westbound lane and crashed into an SUV. Her car and another car collided head-on in the westbound lane.
Hardy suffered a fractured hip and a fractured foot and had her spleen removed, Williams said.
Hardy also faces a count of assault and battery with a dangerous weapon (her car) for injuries to the driver of the other car.
Sanchez did not testify about the speed Hardy was driving. He said he has an opinion about the speed but could not produce scientific proof.
Sanchez said he ruled out environmental or mechanical reasons for the crash, leaving only the human factor. He said the landscaping truck and trailer stopped in the left eastbound lane ahead were visible to a driver going eastbound.
His opinion as to the cause of the crash is that Hardy didn't perceive that the truck and trailer was stopped in sufficient time to take action to avoid losing control.
The driver and the passengers in the landscaping truck testified they were stopped either 30 seconds or a minute waiting to turn before Hardy hit the guard rail.
Sanchez testified Dylan was on the regular seat with a seat belt only, no child seat. He said the car seat in which Jayce was placed was facing forward when it should have been facing backwards and was strapped in too loosely.
Williams, through cross-examination, challenged many points in Sanchez's written report on the crash, as well as his opinions and his testimony that three car or booster seats could have fit in the back seat.
She asked Sanchez if he had ever investigated a crash where sun from behind reflecting on objects was a factor. Sanchez said the sun would have been in back of Hardy, and he has never investigated a serious crash where sun from behind was a contributing factor.
The trial is being held in a small courtroom so the 15 or more family of the two boys are crowded into the two rows on one side of the courtroom and one row of the other side. When court breaks they go upstairs to the district attorney's office with prosecutor James Forsyth and victim witness advocate Margaret Piela.
People who are there with Suzanne Hardy are seated in the remaining row of the other side.
As was the case on other trial days, tears flowed from many people, especially with testimony from the medical examiner and emergency room doctor.