Departing from other witness accounts, Shantell Watson recalled the attacker as being tall, and wearing a red sweatshirt and black hat.
SPRINGFIELD – With one last witness and a flurry of legal motions, testimony in Eric B. Denson’s murder trial concluded Thursday, clearing the way for closing arguments and jury deliberations Friday.
In a unexpected move, the defense decided against calling a DNA analyst from Stockton, Calif., to challenge blood evidence presented by prosecutors during the three-week trial in Hampden Superior Court.
With Denson not scheduled to testify, the defense planned to wrap up its case with the DNA rebuttal from chemist Brian Wraxall of the Serological Research Institute.
Instead, the last defense witness turned out to be Shantell Watson, a 22-year-old Westfield State University student who saw the fatal stabbing of Conor W. Reynolds during a birthday party at the Blue Fusion Bar & Grill on March 13, 2010.
Denson, 22, of Springfield, is facing a first degree murder charge for allegedly stabbing the Cathedral High School senior in the neck after a fight erupted in the crowded St. James Avenue club.
Watson, wearing a pink Westfield State sweatshirt, told jurors she had just come from class to testify in the case. Recalling the night of the fatal stabbing, Watson said she was sitting near the pool table when a light-skinned non-Caucasian male approached Reynolds and thrust a knife into his neck.
“He was trying to force it into (Reynolds’s) neck,” said Watson, adding that she heard someone scream, then ran outside with her friend.
Under questioning from defense lawyer David Rountree, Watson said she got a partial glimpse at the assailant’s face, but a good look at his clothing. Departing from other witness accounts, Watson recalled the attacker as being tall, and wearing a red sweatshirt and black hat.
Earlier in the trial, prosecution witnesses said Reynolds was stabbed by a black male, of medium height, wearing a black leather jacket and red hat.
Watson also said the assailant had fought with two other men minutes before the stabbing – an assertion that no other witnesses had made before Thursday.
Watson said she never met Denson or Reynolds, and attended the party after being invited by a text-message.
During cross-examination by District Attorney Mark G. Mastroianni, Watson said she had expressed confusion about the color of the assailant’s hat, and described it as being red during a pre-trial hearing.
Earlier Thursday, Jessica Green, 25, of East Longmeadow, testified briefly for the defense. A cousin of Denson, Green said she was in Florida on March 13, 2010, but let her brother Michael borrow her 2004 Saturn Vue that night.
She said her mother owned a black leather jacket, and left it back seat of the car.
Surveillance video from a gas station next to the Blue Fusion Bar & Grill showed Denson getting into the car shortly after the stabbing, according to prosecution witnesses.
Investigators later found a blood stain in the Saturn’s back seat with a DNA profile that matched Reynolds, a state police chemist testified last week.
Defense lawyers offered no explanation Thursday for not calling the California-based Wraxall as an expert witness.
But earlier in the trial, the prosecution said it might require Wraxall to testify about his analysis of blood evidence in the case. The suggestion prompted a request by defense lawyer Harry L. Miles for a mistrial, claiming the use of defense evidence against Denson would violate his rights.
Closing arguments are scheduled for 9:30 a.m. Friday in Hampden Superior Court.