The License Commission will take up the bar tonight for an unrelated matter in which an employee allegedly assaulted a patron with a gun.
Updates stories posted at 2:30 a.m. and 4:15 a.m.
SPRINGFIELD -- Duck's Place, the scene of a fatal shooting just after midnight Thursday, was already on the License Commission's agenda tonight for an April incident in which an employee allegedly assaulted a patron with a gun after that man attempted to steal his car.
Detectives, meanwhile, continue to probe the overnight shooting, which took the life of a 24-year-old Holyoke man. Police said the victim was shot multiple times around 12:03 a.m. at the bar’s outdoor patio at the rear of the building, located at the corner of State and Austin streets.
Police have yet to release the victim’s name. Witnesses told officers a heavyset man wearing a baseball cap, white T-shirt and jeans fired several gunshots before fleeing the scene. Additional descriptive information of the suspect has not been released.
The man’s death is the latest in a string of violent crime and other problems that have dogged the storied watering hole, once known as the Café and located at 1146 State St.
The incident is not the first homicide to have occurred there. Patrick Sheklude, a 30-year-old Willard Ave. man, died after being shot twice in the abdomen as he watched another man play a video game at the bar in the summer of 1991.
Drug busts, sales to underage drinkers and city license suspensions have also been a common thread running through the bar's history.
In 2004, Michael Pope, representing the Café during a pre-violation hearing held by the License Commission, said he himself had been stabbed in the bar the year before.
“I know I consider it a successful night when I get home alive. I know that neighborhood is completely and totally out of control,” said Pope, then promotions and security manager for the Café.
On Dec. 2, 2006, the bar -- then known as the Hideway -- was the scene of a double shooting. The License Commission responded by voting in March 2007 to suspend the Hideaway Lounge’s liquor license for three days. Former bar owner Tammy L. Table’s decision to address the problem by firing all workers on duty during the Dec. 2 shooting prompted the commission to issue that penalty instead of a longer suspension.
In 2009, a man was robbed and then shot behind the Hideaway.
In January, the License Commission set a mandatory midnight closing time when it approved a liquor license for the bar's latest incarnation. The all-alcohol license was issued for J.B. King, Inc., doing business as Duck’s Place.
J.B. King, Inc. was organized on Feb. 21, 2013. Located at 101 King St., its registered agent is James J. Bennett Sr.
A police report on the April 2013 assault, which the License Commission will review tonight, states that the incident began when a suspect stole either a patron or employee's car keys from inside the bar and was found outside trying to get inside the vehicle.
The owner of the vehicle, who had a valid license to carry a handgun, fired a warning shot in the air with his 9 mm pistol before eventually detaining the suspect until police arrived, according to the report.
The police report does not describe the owner of the vehicle as an employee of Duck’s Place. The license commission agenda, however, states that an employee assaulted a bar patron with a gun that night.
The vehicle's owner -- Anthony Pearson, 45, of 95 Fargo St. -- was charged with discharging a firearm within 500 feet of a dwelling and assault by means of a dangerous weapon. The alleged car thief, Barry Davis, 28, of 38 Brooks St., was charged with attempted larceny of a motor vehicle, possession of cocaine and larceny under $250.
A Troubled History
Below, a history of incidents involving the bar at 1146 State St., compiled from reports in the archives of The Republican. The bar operated for many years as the Charm Café.
Jan. 9, 1990: City police arrest a man inside the Charm Café and seize a small amount of crack cocaine and $637 in cash.
Aug. 3, 1991: Neighborhood resident Patrick Sheklude is shot and killed inside the Charm Café while watching another patron play a video game. The investigation is hampered by the fact that despite the presence of roughly 50 patrons in the bar at the time of the shooting, few witnesses come forward. Two men are eventually charged, with one convicted of manslaughter and another convicted of second-degree murder.
Aug. 6, 1991: In the wake of the Sheklude murder, City Council candidate Harold F. "Buddy" Langford calls on city officials to "tear up" the Charm Café's liquor license and shut the bar down. Standing next to a sign advertising the Charm as the "cleanest bar in town," Langford rails against the License Commission's inaction despite alleged widespread drug dealing inside and outside the bar. He tells a reporter: "The commission has got to get out in the neighborhoods, and get their heads out of the sand."
Dec. 3, 1991: In a hearing regarding the murder of Patrick Sheklude, the License Commission rules that the Charm Café is not responsible for the shooting because workers could not have anticipated the problem. Commissioners rule that the bar's owners are not guilty of running a disorderly establishment. "This could have happened in Friendly's," Commissioner James Kaufman says. In response to the ruling, Mayor-elect Robert T. Markel vows to seek the resignations of two long-time commissioners. Markel had attacked them in his campaign as lax in enforcing liquor license rules.
March 10, 1993: A 32-year-old city man accused of selling marijuana at the Charm Café is arrested at the bar after detectives allegedly find him in possession of 11 bags of marijuana. A search of his car by police yields an additional six bags of marijuana, 17 rocks of crack cocaine and $389 in cash.
March 29, 1994: A New York City man is shot three times after walking out of the Charm Café by a man who allegedly fired at a crowd of people.
April 10, 1995: Narcotics officers charge a patron at the Charm Café with possession of marijuana with intent to distribute. At the time of the arrest, the bar is in the midst of appealing a 90-day license suspension due to "excessive drug arrests".
May 27, 1999: The Charm Café is fined $100 for selling tobacco to a minor.
July 20, 1999: The agenda for a meeting of the Upper Hill Community Council includes a discussion of complaints involving the Charm Café.
April 2, 2000: Fights inside and outside the Charm Café result in six arrests, several injuries, a report of shots fired and the confiscation by police of a .357 Magnum revolver reported stolen from Belchertown.
Sept. 25, 2001: The Charm Café is one of 40 bars, restaurants and variety stores in Greater Springfield raided in an operation targeting illegal video poker machines.
Sep. 28, 2001: James W. Fiore, who took over as manager of the Charm Café in 1999, lobbies the License Commission to drop a requirement to hire two police officers on Friday nights, telling commissioners he is planning to shift to a restaurant-bar atmosphere. "There is currently not a need for police officers, especially in light of the fact we are going more for a restaurant than a nightclub," Fiore tells the commission. The commission had, at one point, required the bar to have police officers on hand on Thursday, Friday and Saturday nights.
Oct. 23, 2001: The Charm Café hosts a neighborhood meeting for residents and businesses concerned about drug activity in the neighborhood.
Oct. 26, 2001: Fiore is one of a number of Upper Hill residents and business owners participating in a vigil protesting drug activity in the area. "We've had a continued problem with drug sales on these four corners," Fiore tells a reporter, adding: "They stand out all night selling drugs and we need help. We're trying to turn the Charm Café into a restaurant now but a lot of people say, 'I don't want to walk through because of the drugs'."
July 2002-July 2004: Over a two-year period, the state Alcoholic Beverages Control Commission and the city suspend the bar's license a total of 27 days for various violations.
Sept. 6, 2003: A patron of the bar, now known as Peppers Nightclub, is shot and wounded as he is leaving the establishment. Police arrest two men in connection with the shooting. Owners had changed the name to Peppers without properly notifying the city.
Nov. 10, 2003: The Charm Café is included on a list prepared by the License Commission of 11 bars posing "housekeeping" problems for the city – for example, by advertising under names that aren't on file with the city or always being closed when commissioners make regular visits.
June 25, 2004: Two people are arrested at the bar for possession of marijuana. According to one detective's narrative report on the arrest, officers encountered "an overwhelming odor of marijuana" in the bar. "The entire interior of the establishment was blanketed in a smoky haze," the detective wrote. Officers make further marijuana arrests on July 2 and July 18.
July 29, 2004: A License Commission meeting addresses the unauthorized name change of the Charm Café. The bar's promotions and security manager tells the commission, "I know I consider it a successful night when I get home alive. I know that neighborhood is completely and totally out of control." Chairman Peter L. Sygnator tells a reporter he can't envision the bar's operators making enough improvements to prevent a license revocation.
Aug. 12, 2004: The License Commission votes 5-0 to revoke the license of The Charm Café because of repeated violations.
Dec. 2, 2006: Two men are wounded in a double-shooting inside the bar -- which, following the 2004 license revocation, has reopened as the Hideaway Lounge.
March 22, 2007: Citing the December double-shooting, the License Commission votes to suspend the Hideaway Lounge's liquor license for three days. A decision by the bar's owner to fire all workers on duty at the time of the shooting convinces the commission to vote for the shorter suspension, instead of a penalty of at least 30 days recommended by the police department.
May 26, 2009: A patron leaving the bar, now known as the State Street Café, is shot in the leg during a robbery.
Jan., 2013: New owners seek to reopen the bar as Duck's Place. The License Commission approves a liquor license but sets a closing time of midnight. Commission member Denise Kelcey offers the lone vote against the license, siding with representatives from American International College who attend the meeting and urge the commission to deny the license. The college officials tell commissioners there is no need for the bar, and raise concerns that the bar will continue to be a neighborhood trouble spot.
April 26, 2013: A patron or employee of Duck's Place who is a licensed gun owner foils the attempted theft of his vehicle outside the bar, firing a warning shot on State Street before eventually holding the suspect down until police arrive. The incident prompts a new review of the bar's standing with the License Commission. That hearing is scheduled for July 18, 2013.
July 18, 2013: Police respond to Duck's Place at 12:03 a.m. for a report of a shooting and find a 24-year-old Holyoke man who sustained multiple gunshot wounds. The man dies of his injuries.
Staff writers Conor Berry and Dave Canton contributed reporting to this post; assistant online editor Greg Saulmon contributed research.