A report on the financial state of the course, completed by Town Administrator Michael Sullivan, that said the facility was a drain on municipal resources, said the Ledges has lost about $8.5 million, and had never operated in the black since opening in 2001.
SOUTH HADLEY -- The Selectboard on Tuesday decided not to close the municipal Ledges Golf Club, despite its history of financial losses.
After hearing from dozens of residents who spoke for and against moth-balling the financially struggling operation, the board voted unanimously to keep course open at least one more year.
About 125 people attended the meeting at the Town Hall auditorium.
A report on the financial state of the course, completed by Town Administrator Michael Sullivan, found the facility was a drain on municipal resources, losing about $8.5 million never operating in the black since opening in 2001.
Selectman Ira Brezinsky, while expressing concern about the losses -- which he also enumerated during a brief history lesson for the attendees -- said the decision was not just about money.
The selectman hopes the town can sign a five-year lease with a private entity to manage and operate the Ledges. But whether that will come to pass remains to be seen.
The five-member board passed a motion he proposed that states: "Sign renewal with IGM prior to December 1, 2017 to continue maintaining course for one year through December 1, 2018, or as the agreement allows." IGM is a private firm.
The motion also says the Selectboard would "consider seeking [a] golf industry expert to assist in designing and overseeing a request for proposals which would look to find a professional organization for full operation of the golf course."
Members of South Hadley Golf Commission attended the meeting.
In a recent letter to the Selectboard, the commission asked that the facility remain open at least one more year.
"Leasing the property" to a private entity makes sense, Brezinsky said during the Oct. 24 meeting.
Selectman John Hine said he supports giving the Ledges one more chance, for a year's time -- but after that, if financial losses continue to pile up, all bets are off.
"We have tried virtually everything to make this work," he said. "It is clear, this has to be our last shot."
He added: "If we do close the course, it is permanent."
Selectman Bruce Forcier said, "We can't go on forever if it is going to lose money."
The newest member of the board, Andrea Miles, said she had spoken with young families who had moved to town in the past few years.
"No one . . . has said to me they moved to South Hadley because of a golf course," she sai.
During the public comment period, Golf Commission member Chris Collins said, "We ask that the Selectboard vote to keep the Ledges open . . . the Ledges is an important asset to the community."
He promised the commission would work with the administration and Selectboard "to implement a sound financial plan to erase the operational deficits at the Ledges."
South Hadley Appropriations Committee Chairman Thomas Terry asked the board and town administrator the question: "Have we done all we can to improve [the] financial" condition of the Ledges?
Resident Dan Canton said "it is a sin" that the town uses reserve funds to subsidize the golf course.
In "fifteen years years we've lost $8.5 million; it's time to stop," he said.
Retired judge Henry J. Boroff, formerly of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Massachusetts, said the municipal golf course, as a "business has always been hindered by indecision."
Among the things required to make the facility viable, he said, would be an "intense and sustained" advertising campaign.
Normand Cloutier, who was the town's administrator back when the course was built -- and who favors keeping it open -- elicited laughter during his remarks when he said: "I guess I am the guy you can blame for all of it."
Cloutier said it would be a "major mistake" to close the course. "I think we can do better," he said.
Resident Joanna Brown said "as a taxpayer" she wants the town to allocate scarce resources to where they are most needed.
"To me, a golf course falls outside of those parameters," she said.