A Springfield attorney said Geas has "great disdain for informants."
This is an update to a story published at 9:22 p.m. Tuesday.
SPRINGFIELD -- Convicted mob hitman Freddy Geas stole, brawled and killed his way to the top of the organized crime hierarchy in Western Massachusetts in the early 2000s.
Now reportedly a suspect in the death of legendary Boston gangster James J. "Whitey" Bulger Jr. at a high-security West Virginia federal prison Tuesday, his profile as a savage local killer has been raised considerably.
Geas, 51, formerly of West Springfield, has been serving out a life sentence at the Hazelton federal penitentiary in West Virginia since at least 2015. He was among those convicted of the 2003 murders of Springfield mob boss Adolfo "Big Al" Bruno and low-level associate Gary Westerman in 2003 -- plus the near-fatal shooting of a New York union boss the same year.
He and his younger brother, Ty Geas, and Genovese crime boss Arthur "Artie" Nigro, were convicted at trial in 2011 for murder and other crimes. Their undoing was a trusted friend turned government informant. The brothers refused to cooperate and stoically took their life bids while co-conspirators in the murders received lighter sentences.
"Freddy is a dying breed," said Springfield attorney Daniel D. Kelly, who represented both Geases in multiple criminal cases and maintains a friendship with Freddy Geas to this day.
"He has great disdain for informants," Kelly added. "I'm not saying Freddy did this just because the media says so, I'm just telling you what I know about him."
Bulger, on the other hand, was a notorious and duplicitous mob informant for the FBI. He went on the lam from 1995 until 2011, when he was captured by federal agents in California with his longtime girlfriend.
He was convicted of a litany of crimes -- including 11 murders committed while he was on the FBI's payroll -- and was serving a life sentence. Bulger's transfer to the West Virginia prison made national headlines on Monday, and his slaying inside of a day at the facility lit up news outlets around the globe.
U.S. Bureau of Prison officials have yet to release much information about Bulger's death beyond confirming he was discovered in his cell just after 8 a.m. Tuesday morning.
No one has been charged in the killing.
Geas' name first appeared in a story published Tuesday by the Boston Globe.
While speculation in Greater Springfield became rampant by Tuesday afternoon over Geas' possible involvement -- given the common prison setting -- federal officials did not respond to requests for comment.
A 911 dispatch call for an unnamed inmate at the facility revealed an ambulance was summoned for a detainee in cardiac arrest.
No other details emerged during the call, but multiple news outlets have quoted anonymous prison officials saying Bulger, 89, was hastily dragged by up to three inmates in his wheelchair and beaten to death.
Geas has a criminal record dating to his youth, The Republican previously reported during extensive coverage of the Bruno murder.
Freddy and Ty Geas were convicted of conspiring to kill Bruno "cowboy style" outside an Italian social club on Nov. 23, 2003. Freddy Geas hired the gunman who did it, according to court testimony.
Freddy Geas also shot Westerman twice in the head after luring him to a home in Agawam under the guise of a lucrative home invasion, then helped drag him to a freshly dug grave on the property, witnesses said.
The brothers had been riding the coattails of up-and-comer Anthony Arillotta, formally inducted into the Mafia in the spring of 2003 after the trio pumped several bullets into a man on a public street in the Bronx at Nigro's behest.
Arillotta ultimately betrayed them by turning government informant in 2010, after his arrest in the Bruno murder. Arillotta told federal prosecutors he felt badly about selling out his close friends, but entered witness protection and served 99 months in prison in exchange for his testimony against the Geases and others.
Kelly said Arillotta's remorse held no solace for Freddy Geas. The prospect of joining his onetime friend and others as a government witness held no appeal.
"Freddy is a man's man," Kelly said. "After Anthony Arillotta flipped, there was a back channel for Freddy to try to persuade him to cooperate too. He didn't even blink an eye. He didn't flinch. He just said no."
The offer was off the table immediately, even though he knew his cohort aligning with the government meant a certain life sentence, Kelly said.
Kelly also said he maintains a friendship with Geas through frequent emails, having communicated with him just days before Bulger's death.
The subject matter?
"The Patriots. We talk about sports and weather, like everyone else," Kelly said.
He added that of the hundreds of criminal clients he has represented over a 20-year career, Geas is likable and personable in private settings.
A law enforcement source, speaking on condition of anonymity, said that if Geas -- who has exhausted all appeals and post-trial options -- had a hand in killing Bulger, it could guarantee him status in the violent prison culture.
"He's a rich man now. He'll run any prison he's in," the source said.
This story will be updated as more information becomes available.