Since the new indictments were handed down last July, the two sides have been wrestling over the evidence in a series of motions and pretrial conferences.
SPRINGFIELD — The long-awaited murder and arson trial of Anthony P. Baye is scheduled to begin with jury selection in Hampden Superior Court on Monday, some 3 ½ years after Northampton was terrorized by a night of fire.
In the early hours of Dec. 27, 2009, barely two days after Christmas, the rainy night was lit up with house and vehicle fires. Authorities later counted 15 blazes in all. Baye, 28, is charged with setting every one of them, plus five earlier fires in 2009.
For people living in and around the city’s Ward 3, the fires were horrifying because there had been other unexplained fires in the neighborhood over the previous several years. Lots of them. Two years before the night of terror, Ward 3 residents met with police and fire officials and then-Mayor Mary Clare Higgins to voice their fears and demand answers. The meeting was held at the Hampshire Educational Collaborative offices on Hawley Street, next door to the 85 Hawley St. house where Baye lived with his parents.
Northwestern District Attorney David E. Sullivan has called Baye's case the biggest trial in five decades in Northampton.
With the city on high alert after the Dec. 27 fires, police and arson investigators from throughout the state gathered in Northampton. One of the fires, a blaze that destroyed 17 Fair St., took the lives of Paul Yeskie Sr., 81, and his son, Paul Yeskie Jr., 39. The bodies of the two men were found by a window through which they were apparently trying to escape. A harrowing 911 call, preserved on tape, records Paul Yeskie Jr. screaming for his life as the flames closed in.
Baye is charged with two counts of murder for the deaths of the Yeskies, in addition to numerous counts of arson. The trial was originally set to take place in Northampton, with a Hampden County jury transported from Springfield and back every day. However, Judge Constance Sweeney decided to hold the proceedings in Hampden Superior Court, saying the logistics of moving the jurors back and forth was not conducive to an effective trial.
Police had focused on Baye within days of the Dec. 27 fires, in part because he was stopped twice by police that night while driving in that area. On Jan. 4, 2010, state police trooper Michael Mazza, and state police Sgt. Paul Zipper, veteran arson investigators, questioned Baye for 10 hours. The interview, most of which was recorded on video, shows Baye appearing to confess to several of the fires, even going so far as to circle the ones he set. Defense lawyers argued that the troopers overstepped the accepted bounds of police interrogation and appealed to the state’s Supreme Judicial Court. The SJC ruled in Baye’s favor, tossing the confession and most of the interview.
Brett Vottero, who was brought in specially by the Northwestern District Attorney to prosecute the case, dropped nearly all the charges against Baye soon after but brought the case back before a grand jury immediately. This time, Vottero secured indictments not only for the Dec. 27 fires but for 12 other fires set in the area between 2007 and that night. Judge Constance Sweeney has separated prosecution of the 2007 fires from the trial on the 2009 fires.
Since the new indictments were handed down in July, the two sides have been wrestling over the evidence in a series of motions and pretrial conferences. Defense lawyers David P. Hoose and Thomas Lesser won Sweeney’s ruling about the 2007 fires and were successful in their request that Vottero be barred from presenting the lack of fires in the area since Baye’s arrest as evidence of his guilt. Sweeney denied their motion to dismiss the charges, however, and will admit testimony of a conversation between Baye and his parents after he was arrested. In that exchange, the defendant gave an equivocal response when his father asked if he was at the Yeskies’ home on the night of the fire.
The judge has also ruled that Mazza will not be allowed to tell the jury that the Dec. 27 fires and the five earlier ones in 2009 were, in his expert opinion, the work of a single arsonist. Mazza, who has investigated most of the major fires in Western Massachusetts over a long career, has emerged as a central witness in the Baye case. With Baye’s confession ruled out of evidence, the prosecution had relied on Mazza to tie Baye to the fires, particularly the earlier ones. Sweeney on Monday will revisit the question of whether the earlier 2009 fires will remain part of the case starting Monday.
Opening statements are scheduled for Wednesday, followed by a view of the crime scene by the jury. The prosecution will begin calling witnesses on Thursday.