Holyoke, Massachusetts Mayor Alex B. Morse said recently that Jay Ferreira, his opponent in the Nov. 7, 2017 election, uses "scare tactics" in positions on public safety dominated by criticism about fire engine brownouts and a failure to discuss issues with the fire chief, while Ferreira said Morse's decisions have compromised public safety.
HOLYOKE -- Mayor Alex B. Morse said that Jay Ferreira, his opponent in the Nov. 7 election, uses "scare tactics" in public safety positions dominated by criticism of fire engine brownouts and failure to discuss issues with the fire chief.
Ferreira said the browning out, or temporary removal from service, of fire trucks would be unnecessary had Morse embraced his proposal to regionalize and save money by sharing fire service costs with neighboring communities. Ferreira has said brownouts compromise public safety.
"During any election, the issue of public safety is on voters' minds," Morse said in a press release Friday. "Unfortunately, in the case of Jay Ferreira's mayoral candidacy, voters have heard only scare tactics and disingenuous arguments -- arguments belied by the facts, and at odds with Ferreira's own record as a city councilor."
Ferreira's idea for regionalization would have left some Holyoke fire engines unavailable for service here, Morse said. And the mayor questioned why Ferreira in calling for creativity and making public safety a campaign issue has yet to meet with Fire Chief John A. Pond.
"If Jay wants to hear about creative ways to save money and improve services, Chief Pond is exactly the person he should have talked to," Morse said.
Ferreira said that despite Morse's assertion, regionalization of services would result in "significant savings" to taxpayers.
"Those savings would allow Holyoke to reopen Engine 2 and offer relief to overburdened taxpayers at the same time," Ferreira said.
"The mayor is welcome to criticize me all he likes on this topic. If he had any vision himself, he would have done this before choosing to shut down a fire engine," he said.
Morse is running for his fourth term. Ferreira is a former Ward 4 city councilor and current employment coordinator at Community Enterprises here.
Statements from Morse and Ferreira are below.
Ferreira is among those who have criticized Morse and Pond for using brownouts and for removing Engine 2 from service. Reducing available fire trucks leaves the city less safe and is unnecessary,he said.
Pond has said that the plan that involves shifting firefighters from Engine 2 to other trucks would increase the number of firefighters per vehicle on initial responses in an emergency.
Engine 2 is located at Fire Department headquarters and has been the truck that has been "browned out" occasionally.
Brownout is the term used to identify a truck that is removed from service temporarily on a shift when available firefighting staffing is thin. That can happen with vacations, sick days and other matters. Instead of incurring overtime costs by calling in off-duty firefighters to work such shifts, a truck is shut down for a shift and the firefighters on that vehicle temporarily reassigned.
The firefighters union, city councilors such as Daniel B. Bresnahan, the Public Safety Committee chairman, and others have criticized use of brownouts. But Pond and Morse have said that the use of brownouts still maintains sufficient coverage given the strategic locations of fire stations while also saving hundreds of thousands of dollars in employee overtime.
Here is Mayor Alex B. Morse's statement:
During any election, the issue of public safety is on voters' minds.
Unfortunately, in the case of Jay Ferreira's mayoral candidacy, voters have heard only scare tactics and disingenuous arguments -- arguments belied by the facts, and at odds with Ferreira's own record as a city councilor.
Jay Ferreira's whole public safety agenda boils down to his criticism about the "browning out" of Fire Engine #2.
But as a city councilor, when Jay Ferreira actually had a say in how to manage the fire department's budget, he advocated for an even more extreme path, calling for the regionalization of the fire department. In December of 2013, Ferreira filed orders that would have merged Holyoke's fire, building, health, and veterans departments with those of the towns of Southampton and South Hadley. At the time, he wrote, "I believe there is the potential for large savings and no reduction in city services if done properly."
On December 19, 2013, Ferreira shared a MassLive article on his Facebook page -- titled "East Longmeadow considers sharing human resources department with Ludlow" -- and offered the following statement:
"This is the direction we need to be moving in. There is so much money to be saved. We could basically take over the entire government of Southampton and some of South Hadley's. I filed an order to do some of this with four city departments. Creativity and an open mind will equal savings."
Voters need to understand: had Ferreira gotten his way in 2013, some Holyoke engines would have been put out of service. And in much the same way the fire union has criticized Mayor Morse's redistribution plan, the union was highly critical of Ferreira's plan in 2013.
"I like Jay, and believe he cares about the city," Mayor Morse says. "But this shows that he's willing to take positions for political advantage."
Jay Ferreira was right when he called for "creativity" and "an open mind" in addressing the city's financial challenges. But as a candidate for mayor, he has instead chosen to echo the talking points of political allies.
Moreover, despite making fire safety a centerpiece of his campaign, Jay Ferreira has still not reached out to Fire Chief Pond to discuss the department and its needs. At no time in the seven months since Ferreira pulled nomination papers to run for mayor has he prioritized meeting with the chief.
"It is truly astounding that a candidate for mayor wouldn't even reach out to the chief to have a conversation," Mayor Morse says. "If Jay wants to hear about creative ways to save money and improve services, Chief Pond is exactly the person he should have talked to."
Throughout his time in office, Mayor Morse has managed to cut overall spending while guaranteeing fire protection to the people of Holyoke. Since Mayor Morse took office, the city has purchased three new fire trucks, hired 37 new firefighters, and received nearly $3.3 million in federal grants to hire firefighters and buy radios and other gear. According to the Insurance Service Organization, Holyoke's fire protection has improved on Mayor Morse's watch.
Here is mayoral candidate Jay Ferreira's statement:
I'm not sure if this is supposed to be some kind of criticism but I'm glad the mayor brought it up. Working together with surrounding communities is one of Holyoke's best opportunities to see significant savings in the city budget. Those savings would allow Holyoke to reopen Engine #2 and offer relief to overburdened taxpayers at the same time.
This option isn't limited to the Fire Department. There are potential savings in almost every city department. We absolutely need to be meeting with leaders from surrounding communities to identify areas where working together can save money while maintaining city services. The mayor is welcome to criticize me all he likes on this topic. If he had any vision himself, he would have done this before choosing to shut down a fire engine.