With the Town of Hampden considering possible legal action to keep Thornton W. Burgess Middle School open, Hampden-Wilbraham Regional School Committee Chairman Bill Bontempi says he'll fight to make sure that providing a strong education to all HWRSD students remains the paramount priority of the seven-member panel.
WILBRAHAM -- With the Town of Hampden considering possible legal action to keep Thornton W. Burgess Middle School open, Hampden-Wilbraham Regional School Committee Chairman Bill Bontempi says he'll fight to make sure that providing a strong education to all HWRSD students remains the paramount priority of the seven-member panel.
"As a member of the School Committee, I could never, ever in good conscience put the education of our children in the backseat because of a potential legal challenge," Bontempi said at the board's Oct. 19 meeting, receiving a hearty round of applause from audience members..
"I just can't do it," he said.
Moments later, the panel voted 4-3 to implement Superintendent Albert G. Ganem Jr.'s five-year reorganization plan for the Hampden-Wilbraham district. The most immediate impact will be the closure of TWB, as the school named after children's author Thornton W. Burgess is known, at the end of the current academic year.
By July 1, 2018, the 50-year-old building will officially be returned to the Town of Hampden, leaving Green Meadows Elementary School as Hampden's only educational facility in the seven-school district. Under the districtwide school reconfiguration plan, Green Meadows will absorb the middle school students from TWB, some of whom are also likely to transfer to Wilbraham Middle School -- a process that requires permission from district officials.
Other changes will be phased in as the rollout continues over the next five years. Among the scheduled changes are closing a school in Wilbraham and reconfiguring Minnechaug Regional High School into a 7-12 school by the 2022-23 academic year. Minnechaug currently serves grades 9-12.
None of this is ideal, school board members and district officials acknowledge, which is why nearly all of them still support moving TWB students to Wilbraham Middle School to mitigate ongoing declining enrollment across the district, but particularly at the middle school level.
However, the so-called unification plan was shot down by voters in Hampden last fall, leading to the creation and implementation of Ganem's staggered reorganization plan, which calls for shrinking the seven-school district to five schools in the coming years. That process will begin with the closure of TWB several months from now.
Bontempi's concerns about possible legal action from Hampden are not unfounded.
Town voters will be asked to consider deregionalization articles at Hampden's fall meeting next week, including using $50,000 to cover the cost of a possible injunction to stop TWB from closing or other legal fees related to modifying the regional school agreement between Hampden and Wilbraham.
Leaving the regional school district, a costly and potentially lengthy process, would require approval from voters in both towns and authorization by the state Department of Education.
School Committee member Mary Ellen Glover, who supports maintaining two schools in Hampden, said adopting the reorganization and school-closing plan could become a legal liability for the regional school district.
"I envision that if you pass this plan, the likelihood that legal action will be taken is increased," she said shortly before the school board voted to adopt Ganem's plan.
Glover, a Hampden resident, questioned whether the district could "afford to pay the legal bills for this issue," appealing to her colleagues to be empathetic to Hampden's perspective.
"If you put yourself in the position of Hampden residents and you see the emotion that they bring to the table when they're discussing this issue, I think you have to say, 'Can't we do better? Can't we come up with something that everybody can embrace?'" she said. "I think we can."
A lawsuit is not the right way to go about things, according to School Committee member Sean Kennedy. "A lawsuit is not logic. A lawsuit is emotion," said Kennedy, one of five Wilbraham residents on the seven-member board.
"If there is a legal challenge," Bontempi said, "I will be the first one to stand up and make sure that the voices of these children are heard and that education is the primary responsibility of this committee."
Patrick Kiernan, one of three school board members to vote against the reorganization plan -- the others were Glover and Sherrill Caruana -- pointed out that both towns, which formed the regional district in 1994, will have lost 50 percent of their schools by the time the reorganization plan is fully implemented.
"The biggest piece that I continue to hear is ... that people feel one side is losing far too much and the other is not sacrificing enough," Kiernan said.
Immediately after the vote to adopt the five-year plan, the School Committee agreed to draft two warrant articles to present to Hampden and Wilbraham voters in January.
Both articles pertain to amending the regional school agreement to allow students to cross town lines. Under the current agreement, Hampden and Wilbraham students are required to be educated in their hometowns until high school, grades 9-12, when all students attend Minnechaug in Wilbraham.
The first article would allow Hampden students in grades 7-8 to cross town lines to attend Wilbraham Middle School. The second would allow Hampden sixth-graders to also cross town lines to attend Wilbraham Middle School. If neither article passes, the school district will move forward with converting Green Meadows, presently a K-5 school, into a K-8 school.
"If there are modifications to the regional agreement, then that plan can change," Bontempi said.
After last week's lengthy School Committee meeting, Bontempi commended the Hampden residents who are opposed to the concept of unifying all district middle school students on a single campus in Wilbraham.
"Although I do not agree with their opinion, I admire their resolve," Bontempi said in an Oct. 20 post on his Facebook page, "Bill Bontempi HWRSD School Committee," saying the opposition inspired district officials to step up their game and devise the reorganization plan.
"Moreover, the School Committee and the residents of both towns owe these individuals a debt of gratitude," Bontempi said. "Through their stalwart resistance, they forced the School Committee and the school administration to look harder and dig deeper for alternatives. In doing so we were able to devise this five-year plan."
Now is the time to look forward, he said, not backwards.
"For those contemplating legal action against the school district, please remember every dollar that we spend in court is one dollar less then (sic) we have to spend on children's education," Bontempi said.
"And so, if the individuals who oppose this plan are truly advocates for children and for education, their threat of legal action should end today," he said.